Buying Management Equity at Fair Market Value? What to Check Before You Wire Funds

If you’re buying management equity with your own cash, confirm what you are acquiring, how the company valued that interest, and when ownership actually transfers before you wire funds. A price labeled “fair market value” can affect the tax calculation, but it does not answer whether the transfer is connected to your services or whether a Section 83(b) election makes sense.

1. Identify the interest and read the employment terms alongside it

Start with the legal issuer and its U.S. tax classification. Corporate stock, a capital interest in a partnership, a profits interest, and a contractual promise of a future payout can produce different results. For a partnership, the rights to existing value on a hypothetical immediate liquidation help distinguish a capital interest from a profits interest. Qualifying profits interests have separate IRS guidance with conditions; an award label alone does not establish eligibility. See Revenue Procedure 2001-43 and our management equity and profits interests guide.

Read the subscription agreement together with the equity plan, governing agreement and employment terms. Was the opportunity available because of your role? What happens to the interest or the price you receive on repurchase if you leave before vesting or an exit? If one document describes a cash investment and another ties the transfer to services, resolve the difference before signing. Paying cash does not by itself put a transfer outside Section 83. Whether a restriction creates a substantial risk of forfeiture depends on its terms and the facts; a repurchase clause alone does not settle it.

2. Ask what the fair market value actually measures

Ask for the valuation date, the class valued, and the support for applying that value on the proposed transfer date. If the report is confidential, ask what summary or adviser access can be provided. Check for intervening financing, acquisitions or other material changes. Review the class’s participation threshold, investor preferences and payout waterfall. A percentage of a class and an illustrative payout at exit do not establish the current fair market value of your interest.

When Section 83 applies, the calculation generally uses fair market value without regard to restrictions that will lapse; qualifying nonlapse restrictions are treated differently. A company’s valuation or a price agreed in the deal documents is evidence to evaluate. A tax review can assess the support and identify gaps; an independent valuation is separate work.

3. Confirm the transfer date and decide who handles the election

If an election is appropriate, it generally must be filed no later than 30 days after the property transfer. Identify when beneficial ownership passes using the agreement, closing conditions, approvals and issuance records. The wire date, signature date and ownership date may differ. A draft election from the company does not establish that the transfer has occurred or that anyone filed it.

Review the current IRS Form 15620 and instructions and the IRS’s online filing option. Agree who will file, who must receive copies, and where you’ll keep the signed election and submission or mailing evidence. Compare the timing benefit with the risk of paying tax upfront on an interest you could later forfeit. Section 83 generally does not allow a deduction for the compensation previously included under an election if the property is forfeited.

4. Find out what you’ll report before exit

Ask the issuer for a written explanation of its U.S. tax classification, when you are treated as an owner for tax purposes, and what tax documents it expects to provide each year. If someone says “no K-1 until exit,” ask what supports that answer. A partner can have taxable allocations without receiving cash; check the tax distribution policy and what happens if distributions are insufficient. Corporate stock follows a different reporting framework. See the IRS instructions for partners receiving Schedule K-1.

If you will hold a foreign interest, get the ownership chart and each entity’s jurisdiction and classification. Use those facts, your tax status and any applicable thresholds to evaluate separate reporting, including Form 8938 where relevant. A foreign sponsor’s involvement alone does not tell you which forms apply.

What to gather before you wire funds

  • Deal documents: Subscription agreement, equity plan, governing agreement, capitalization information and rights for your class.
  • Employment and departure terms: Vesting, forfeiture, repurchase pricing and what happens if you leave before an exit.
  • Valuation and economics: Valuation date and support for your class, purchase price, participation thresholds and payout waterfall.
  • Closing and election: Expected closing and transfer dates, issuance records when available, draft election and who is responsible for filing and retaining proof.
  • Annual reporting: Entity chart, expected tax forms, allocation rules and the tax distribution policy.

Frequently asked questions

Is a Section 83(b) election required just because the company included one?

A draft is a reason to review the transaction promptly. First determine whether eligible property is being transferred in connection with services, then assess whether making the election is advisable. The company’s draft cannot make that decision for you.

What if I leave before the company sells?

Check which interests can be forfeited or repurchased, how the price is set, and when payment is due. Review the tax consequences of a buyback separately from those of a company sale. See what happens to management equity when you leave.

Is an exit illustration enough to decide whether to invest?

Use it to understand the assumptions, then compare it with the actual waterfall and your class’s rights. A company can sell at a substantial price without a payout to a particular class. See why a large sale may produce no management equity payout.

Review the buy-in before you commit

Bring the proposed documents and identify your earliest signing, payment or election deadline. For the wider compensation package, see PE-backed executive offer review.

Schedule a $500 Tax Attorney Consultation

The fee covers up to one hour total of review, analysis, preparation and the telephone consultation. A written assessment, detailed valuation analysis, independent appraisal, modeling or election filing requires a separately agreed scope. Use the secure upload step for documents. Scheduling does not extend any deadline.

Federal authorities checked November 11, 2026. General legal and tax information; the result depends on the documents, facts and tax year.

Your Executive Bonus Goals Will Be Set After You Start: What Should You Resolve First?

If an executive offer leaves bonus goals to be agreed after hiring, resolve the process, measurement rules and consequences of disagreement before relying on the target amount. The same goals may also determine whether later equity is granted or vested.

Establish what is promised before you start

A target bonus percentage identifies an opportunity, but may not establish the amount earned, the required performance or the payment obligation. If the offer says targets will be mutually agreed later, read what happens if agreement is delayed or never reached. Do not assume the target becomes guaranteed by default.

Obtain the incentive plan, definitions, exhibits and approval requirements. Compare the offer with provisions allowing the employer to modify or discontinue the plan. Ask which document controls if they conflict and which commitments require board or compensation-committee approval.

Define the baseline and the calculation

A workable scorecard identifies the measurement period, data source, baseline, threshold, target, maximum and weight for each metric. For EBITDA or budget-based goals, determine which accounting definitions and adjustments apply and whether acquisitions, divestitures, capital spending or extraordinary costs change the calculation.

  • What improvement is already included in the operating plan?
  • Are savings credited when identified, implemented, booked or sustained?
  • How are shared initiatives and changes outside the executive’s authority treated?
  • Who supplies the data, certifies the results and resolves disagreements?
  • Can metrics change during the performance year, and with what consent?
  • If the role starts midyear, how are the performance period and bonus prorated?

Invented example: A company’s approved budget already includes $4 million of annual savings. The new executive’s bonus counts only additional savings. Delivering the budgeted $4 million may produce no credited improvement under that metric. Identify the baseline and incremental-credit rules before assigning value to the target bonus.

Resolve disagreement and delay in writing

Possible negotiating points include a signed initial scorecard, a defined process and deadline for adjustments, an agreed first-year minimum or a specified alternative formula if targets are not approved on time. These are proposed contractual protections, not benefits the executive automatically receives.

Use a schedule that identifies the responsible decision-maker, required approvals and method for recording agreement. Avoid relying on an informal promise that the parties will work it out after relocation or resignation. The executive offer-review checklist connects the bonus review with the rest of the package.

Check whether the same goals also gate equity

A single performance score may control both cash compensation and later equity grants. Missing an undefined or disputed target can therefore affect more than one component. Determine whether the equity is already granted subject to vesting or whether performance merely creates eligibility for a future grant.

Read the equity plan and award independently. Confirm how an early sale, changed role or termination affects an incomplete measurement period. A bonus exception does not necessarily preserve the equity. See profits interests and management equity and management equity after termination.

Separate performance achievement from payment conditions

Review the certification date, payment deadline, active-employment requirement and treatment of resignation or notice of termination. Determine what happens to an otherwise earned bonus if employment ends without cause or the executive leaves for good reason.

Applicable wage law can limit contractual forfeiture. For covered Colorado employees, the Department of Labor and Employment’s INFO #3D on commissions and bonuses addresses whether compensation is earned, vested and determinable. Valid conditions established in advance and an attempt to forfeit already-earned wages require different analysis. Coverage, location, facts and governing law matter; an executive role outside Colorado may require another state’s analysis.

Our bonus-agreement guide addresses earning, vesting and payment in more detail. For deferred arrangements, the payment schedule and actual administration may require Section 409A review; the federal regulation includes the short-term-deferral framework and its conditions.

Preserve a complete performance record

Keep the signed plan and scorecard, baseline reports, approved changes, calculations, certification communications and payment records. Compare the final documents with the offer and retain written confirmation of any first-year arrangement. A factual record can be important when the parties later disagree about the measurement or payment conditions.

Common questions

Is a target bonus guaranteed?

Not simply because the offer states a target percentage. The plan, performance conditions, discretion, payment terms and applicable law determine the obligation.

Can the employer change goals after I start?

Review the reserved amendment power and any consent requirement. Whether a particular change is effective or can affect earned compensation requires the agreement, facts and applicable law.

Does meeting the bonus target guarantee my equity grant?

Only if the controlling equity terms provide that result. Approval requirements, grant conditions, vesting and continued-employment provisions may differ from the cash-bonus plan.

Resolve the performance terms before committing

Discuss the proposed documents and your earliest deadline with Philip Falco, Attorney & CPA.

Schedule a $500 Tax Attorney Consultation

The fee includes up to one hour of total attorney time for review, analysis, preparation and the telephone consultation combined. Comprehensive document review, financial or tax modeling, valuation work, drafting, negotiation, filings and ongoing representation require a separate written engagement.

Authorities checked October 21, 2026. General legal and tax information. The result depends on the documents, applicable law, entity structure and tax year. Scheduling a consultation does not extend a signing, payment or election deadline.

Make-Whole Compensation: Replacing Equity You Forfeit When Changing Jobs

Make-whole compensation is intended to replace compensation lost when changing jobs. Its usefulness depends on the replacement’s vesting, payment, forfeiture and tax terms, as well as the amount stated in the offer.

Identify exactly what departure would forfeit

List each existing award, its grant date, vesting dates, performance conditions and treatment on resignation. Record current value and the basis for that value. Include a pending annual bonus where relevant, but distinguish an enforceable entitlement from an estimate of likely payment.

Then identify future annual grants you would no longer receive. Replacing an existing award does not necessarily replace the ongoing incentive program. The public-company-to-PE compensation comparison shows how to keep those entries separate.

Compare replacement rights rather than headline values

Questions for a make-whole arrangement
Term Question to resolve
Amount and instrument Cash, public stock, private stock, profits interest or a payment promise?
Valuation How was the replacement amount determined, and when is it measured?
Vesting and payment Does the new schedule extend the original wait or add performance conditions?
Termination What survives termination without cause, good reason, disability or death?
Repayment Which events trigger repayment, for how long, and on a gross or net basis?
Sale treatment Does an early sale accelerate payment or eliminate an unissued award?
Approvals and obligor Which entity owes the benefit, and are all required approvals complete?
Tax and reporting When is income recognized, how is it reported, and is cash available for taxes?

A promise in an offer may be subject to another document’s terms or board approval. Review priority clauses and make the intended replacement obligation consistent across the offer, award and governing agreements.

A replacement can add a new risk of loss

Invented example: An executive would forfeit $160,000 of restricted shares scheduled to vest in eight months. The new employer offers a private award described as worth $160,000, vesting over four years and payable only after a sale. If termination before sale cancels the award, the proposal adds service, business and liquidity risks. Equal stated values do not establish equivalent benefits.

Possible negotiating approaches include cash, a shorter vesting schedule, a cash-and-equity combination, protection on specified involuntary departures or separate replacement and upside awards. None is automatically appropriate; cost, tax, enforceability and the employer’s financial capacity still matter.

Review clawbacks and the amount you could owe

Signing and replacement payments may require repayment after an early resignation or termination for cause. Define the trigger, repayment period, proration, deadline and any offset against other compensation. Determine whether repayment includes taxes paid through a gross-up and whether protections apply if the company ends employment without cause.

A prior-year repayment can raise separate tax issues. IRS Publication 525’s repayment guidance discusses circumstances in which deductions, credits or payroll-tax adjustments may be relevant. A contractual obligation to repay gross compensation does not establish that all associated taxes will be recovered. Obtain tax analysis for the actual payment and repayment years.

Match the instrument to the tax analysis

A replacement payment does not inherit the old award’s tax treatment merely because it is called make-whole. Actual stock, partnership interests and deferred cash promises follow different frameworks. Publication 541 explains partnership interests for services; Revenue Procedure 2001-43 addresses qualifying substantially nonvested profits interests.

Read the profits-interest guide or phantom-equity guide as appropriate. A change to payment timing can also need Section 409A review. Preserve the existing award records, proposed replacement agreement, actual transfer dates and any required election evidence.

Common questions

Does make-whole compensation have to be cash?

No. The parties may negotiate cash, equity or another arrangement. The instrument and its conditions determine how well it replaces the rights being surrendered.

Does matching the current award value make me whole?

Not necessarily. Compare vesting, performance, forfeiture, payment timing, tax and liquidity, as well as the number used to describe the award.

Should the replacement award be separate from the ordinary equity incentive?

Separate documentation or clearly identified components can make the bargain easier to evaluate. Confirm which value replaces existing awards and which rewards future service or performance.

Review the replacement before surrendering existing awards

Discuss the proposed documents and your earliest deadline with Philip Falco, Attorney & CPA.

Schedule a $500 Tax Attorney Consultation

The fee includes up to one hour of total attorney time for review, analysis, preparation and the telephone consultation combined. Comprehensive document review, financial or tax modeling, valuation work, drafting, negotiation, filings and ongoing representation require a separate written engagement.

Authorities checked October 21, 2026. General legal and tax information. The result depends on the documents, applicable law, entity structure and tax year. Scheduling a consultation does not extend a signing, payment or election deadline.

Leaving a Public Company for Private Equity: How to Compare Executive Compensation

A PE-backed offer can show a larger projected payout while providing less dependable compensation. Compare annual opportunities, existing awards forfeited and private-equity proceeds separately, using the same period and explicit assumptions.

Separate annual compensation from existing awards

A recurring long-term incentive opportunity and an existing unvested award are different entries. The first concerns future compensation opportunities you may lose. The second concerns compensation rights already granted that departure may affect. Review award periods and vesting records to avoid counting the same value twice.

Also separate grant-date target value from current market value and eventual cash proceeds. Public-company awards can fluctuate or be forfeited. Private-company awards can provide substantial upside, but transfer restrictions, investor priorities and uncertain liquidity make headline values difficult to compare.

Build a comparison over the same period

The figures below are invented and describe target compensation value, not cash guaranteed or received. Assume three full years of service and full target bonus achievement. Assume the current employer makes a new annual long-term award targeted at $150,000, separate from $180,000 of existing awards retained by staying and forfeited by moving.

Invented three-year compensation comparison
Component Stay at public company Join PE-backed company
Annual base salary $280,000 $300,000
Annual target bonus $84,000 $90,000
Annual target long-term award $150,000 No recurring grant assumed
Three-year annual target total $1,542,000 $1,170,000 before private equity
Separate existing awards retained or replaced $180,000 retained No replacement assumed
One-time signing payment None assumed $40,000
Total comparison value $1,722,000 $1,210,000 before private equity

On these assumptions, the private-company equity would need to deliver $512,000 before tax to match the nominal comparison value. That amount provides no additional compensation for greater uncertainty or waiting for cash. It excludes taxes, benefit differences, moving costs, investment returns and discounting. Actual public awards may settle outside the three-year period and at different values.

Change the period and assumptions if the expected exit moves. An extra year may add another public-company award opportunity while leaving the private-company allocation unchanged. A company’s proposed sale date is an assumption unless the documents provide an enforceable payment right.

Calculate proceeds under the actual private award

Obtain the issuer, instrument, fully diluted percentage and distribution waterfall. Determine whether participation starts with current capital value or only above a hurdle. Model preferred returns, new capital, debt, expenses, dilution and staged grants. Our management-equity guide explains why an interest’s label does not establish its economics.

Ask the company to reconcile the offer, illustration and governing documents using identical assumptions. A chart showing a percentage of all equity value cannot establish a payout when the award participates in a different pool. See executive offer review for the complete document checklist.

Assess the company and the conditions together

Public reporting and a trading market may provide more information and liquidity for an established public company’s shares. They do not guarantee continued employment, bonus achievement or award value. A PE-backed business may have strong operations and substantial upside; sponsorship alone does not establish either quality or safety.

  • Business: earnings quality, cash flow, debt obligations and customer concentration.
  • Sponsor economics: invested capital, preferred returns, expected holding period and future funding needs.
  • Employment: termination rights, severance, restrictive covenants and relocation commitments.
  • Equity: vesting, repurchase, information rights, tax distributions and liquidity.
  • Concentration: salary, bonus and equity may all deteriorate with the same business.

Use scenarios that show the actual consequences of a lower sale value, a delayed exit, termination before exit and no liquidity during the comparison period. Do not select a risk premium or probability merely because it makes the new offer appear attractive.

Negotiate the gaps the comparison reveals

Discuss recurring cash compensation, a separate replacement for existing awards, defined performance goals and protection for earned equity. Identify who must approve the changes and incorporate them into the controlling documents. Make-whole arrangements and departure protections address different risks and should be compared separately.

Review the tax character and payment schedule of each component. IRS Publication 541 addresses actual partnership interests; phantom compensation and deferred payments require their own analysis. A nominal pretax comparison is not an after-tax financial plan.

Common questions

Is private-company equity equivalent to public-company stock?

No. The instruments can have different economic rights, transfer restrictions, liquidity and tax treatment. Even public-company awards may be restricted or contingent.

Can I treat a projected exit value as annual compensation?

A projected exit amount should be modeled over its expected payment period and under the actual award terms. It should not be added to every year’s salary as though it were an annual payment.

Compare the complete compensation packages

Discuss the proposed documents and your earliest deadline with Philip Falco, Attorney & CPA.

Schedule a $500 Tax Attorney Consultation

The fee includes up to one hour of total attorney time for review, analysis, preparation and the telephone consultation combined. Comprehensive document review, financial or tax modeling, valuation work, drafting, negotiation, filings and ongoing representation require a separate written engagement.

Authorities checked October 21, 2026. General legal and tax information. The result depends on the documents, applicable law, entity structure and tax year. Scheduling a consultation does not extend a signing, payment or election deadline.

Does Your Executive Release Cover Equity Claims and Tax Liabilities?

An executive release may cover more than employment discrimination. It can address ownership, distributions, contract claims, prior tax advice and liability for compensation-plan failures. Read those provisions with the redemption and payment terms.

Identify the Claims and Parties Covered

Look for affiliates, sponsors, officers, advisers and successors in the definition of released parties. Review equity claims, unknown claims, fraud or misrepresentation language, fiduciary-duty allegations and tax-related claims. Their inclusion does not by itself establish enforceability under every applicable law.

Check exclusions for the right to enforce the new payment promise, vested benefits, specified retained interests and other rights that cannot lawfully be waived. An exclusion should be compared with any separate acknowledgment that all compensation or equity payments have already been received.

Tax Disclaimers and Indemnities Serve Different Purposes

A tax disclaimer may state that the company does not guarantee a particular result. An indemnity may require the executive to reimburse taxes, interest, penalties or expenses. A release may waive certain claims against the company if its plan creates tax exposure. Identify each obligation and any limitation, defense procedure or survival term.

These provisions do not decide the correct tax characterization of a bonus, ownership redemption or settlement. Nor does contractual §409A-compliance language establish that a plan’s terms and administration satisfy the deferred-compensation rules.

Protected Claims Require a Separate Review

Federal age-discrimination waivers have specific consideration, timing and disclosure requirements. The ADEA waiver statute distinguishes ordinary departure waivers from settlement of a filed charge or lawsuit. The EEOC guidance also explains that an agreement cannot bar filing a charge or participating in an EEOC proceeding. State wage rights and other statutory protections need their own analysis.

Coordinate the Release With Payment Timing

Signing and revocation dates can affect when money is payable. A covered §409A arrangement should not give the executive impermissible control over the payment year through release timing. IRS Notice 2010-80 addresses release-dependent payment provisions and correction methods subject to conditions.

Bring the release, award agreements, bonus terms, tax indemnities, prior amendments and payment calendar to executive severance, redemption and release review. Assess the rights surrendered and risks assumed together.

Review the Agreement Before You Sign

Schedule a $500 Tax Attorney Consultation

The fee includes up to one hour of total attorney time for review, analysis, preparation and the telephone consultation combined. Comprehensive document review, calculations, valuation work, drafting, negotiation, tax returns and ongoing representation require a separate written engagement. Identify the earliest signing, election or payment deadline when requesting the consultation.

Authorities checked October 7, 2026. General legal and tax information. The result depends on the governing documents, applicable law, transaction and tax year. Scheduling a consultation does not extend a deadline.

Why a Large Company Sale May Produce No Management Equity Payout

A large transaction price does not tell an executive what their incentive award receives. Sale proceeds may first satisfy debt, expenses and investor priorities. Management participation may begin only after specified hurdles are met.

Start With the Issuing Entity

An executive might hold units in a parent partnership while a subsidiary sells a business. Determine what consideration the seller receives and how value moves through the ownership structure. The transaction price and the amount distributable by the issuer can be different.

Follow the Contractual Waterfall

Read debt and expense deductions, investor capital returns, preferred returns, participation thresholds, catch-up provisions and management allocations. Distinguish enterprise value from equity value and total equity proceeds from the pool in which the particular award participates.

A Simplified Illustration

Assume a $90 million sale produces $55 million after debt and expenses. If investors must receive $60 million before a management class participates, that class receives no proceeds under the simplified waterfall. The figures are invented, and actual debt, preferences, prior distributions and catch-up provisions could change the result.

Economic Participation and Vesting Are Separate

An executive can satisfy service vesting while the award remains below its economic hurdle. A performance condition can also remain unsatisfied even if a different award produces a bonus. Review each instrument independently.

The profits-interest guide explains capital and profits interests; transaction bonuses may use a separate payment formula. Phantom compensation also follows its own plan terms.

No Payout Does Not Resolve Every Other Question

Determine whether the award remains outstanding for later distributions or has ended through a governing provision or separate agreement. Retained partnership ownership can also involve taxable allocations without matching cash. Publication 541 explains that partners report their distributive shares.

Request the ownership chart, waterfall calculation, award vesting statement and transaction proceeds schedule. If a surrender or release is proposed, assess it under executive release and redemption review.

Review the Agreement Before You Sign

Schedule a $500 Tax Attorney Consultation

The fee includes up to one hour of total attorney time for review, analysis, preparation and the telephone consultation combined. Comprehensive document review, calculations, valuation work, drafting, negotiation, tax returns and ongoing representation require a separate written engagement. Identify the earliest signing, election or payment deadline when requesting the consultation.

Authorities checked October 7, 2026. General legal and tax information. The result depends on the governing documents, applicable law, transaction and tax year. Scheduling a consultation does not extend a deadline.

The Company Says Your Equity Is Worthless: What Information Should You Request?

A statement that incentive equity has no value can describe current liquidation proceeds, a particular sale, a repurchase formula or the company’s view of future prospects. Ask which meaning is intended before surrendering the interest.

Ask for the Calculation and Its Date

Identify the issuing entity, units outstanding, valuation date and applicable hurdle. Request the distribution waterfall, debt and transaction expenses, preferred rights, investor proceeds and relevant prior distributions. Compare the calculation with the actual agreement rather than a headline sale price.

A zero share in a hypothetical liquidation can be consistent with a profits-interest structure. It does not, by itself, answer every future-value or ownership question. See profits interests and management equity.

Clarify What Remains

Ask whether the entity retains businesses, cash, escrow, earnouts, claims or other assets, and whether a winding-up process is complete. Determine whether later receipts could affect the waterfall. A completed divestiture and a completed liquidation are different events.

Also ask whether the interests remain outstanding. If the company says they were forfeited, repurchased or canceled, request the contractual provision, effective date and relevant notice or ownership record.

A Request Is Different From an Enforceable Records Demand

Information rights depend on the entity, holder status, agreement, law and purpose of the request. For example, Delaware’s limited-partnership records statute, §17-305 and LLC records statute, §18-305 provide frameworks with purpose, confidentiality, procedural and contractual limitations. Being a Colorado resident does not make Colorado entity law govern a Delaware issuer.

Counsel can assess a voluntary request or formal demand. Do not assume a former employee, phantom-award holder and continuing owner have identical access rights.

Separate Economic Value From Tax Worthlessness

The company’s statement does not automatically establish a deductible worthless-interest loss. Basis, the tax year, liabilities and whether the event is a sale, abandonment or another disposition can change the result. See IRS Publication 541 and the existing partnership-exit resources.

If the statement accompanies a payment conditioned on surrender, review the proposed redemption and release alongside the supporting financial records.

Review the Agreement Before You Sign

Schedule a $500 Tax Attorney Consultation

The fee includes up to one hour of total attorney time for review, analysis, preparation and the telephone consultation combined. Comprehensive document review, calculations, valuation work, drafting, negotiation, tax returns and ongoing representation require a separate written engagement. Identify the earliest signing, election or payment deadline when requesting the consultation.

Authorities checked October 7, 2026. General legal and tax information. The result depends on the governing documents, applicable law, transaction and tax year. Scheduling a consultation does not extend a deadline.

Can Performance Equity Continue Vesting After Termination?

Performance equity can sometimes remain outstanding after employment ends and vest when a later condition is satisfied. Whether that occurs depends on the award, plan, governing agreement and amendments. Continued vesting is a contractual question before it becomes a payout calculation.

Separate Service Conditions From Performance Conditions

An award might vest in part through service and in part through a future sale or investor-return threshold. Leaving before that event may ordinarily cause forfeiture. A special termination exception may preserve the performance opportunity without accelerating payment.

Consider an invented award that requires an investor-return threshold. A later amendment preserves that opportunity for an executive terminated without cause. The executive’s departure would not, by itself, prove either that the threshold was achieved or that the interest was forfeited. The full terms control.

Read the Latest Applicable Amendment

A qualified-termination provision can override earlier language for specified circumstances. Confirm its effective date, covered awards and definition. Divestiture-related provisions may depend on continued service with a purchaser or the reason for a later termination.

Identify notice and cure requirements, decision-making authority and evidence of the actual termination. An exception in a cash-bonus agreement may differ from an exception in an equity award.

Preserved Vesting Is Not a Guaranteed Distribution

Even if the award survives, performance conditions, debt, investor preferences and the distribution waterfall can leave it without a current payout. Also review repurchase options, transfer restrictions and later breach provisions. See management-equity economics.

Keep Tax Definitions Separate

A contractual termination category is not automatically the §409A separation-from-service definition. Continued consulting services can affect that tax determination for covered compensation. See Treasury Regulation §1.409A-1(h).

If actual partnership ownership continues, tax allocations and reporting may continue as well. Reconcile the ownership event and K-1 treatment under Publication 541 rather than assuming the last day of employment is the last day as an owner.

Bring the complete award history and departure notices to a management-equity departure review before signing a document that waives the preserved rights.

Review the Agreement Before You Sign

Schedule a $500 Tax Attorney Consultation

The fee includes up to one hour of total attorney time for review, analysis, preparation and the telephone consultation combined. Comprehensive document review, calculations, valuation work, drafting, negotiation, tax returns and ongoing representation require a separate written engagement. Identify the earliest signing, election or payment deadline when requesting the consultation.

Authorities checked October 7, 2026. General legal and tax information. The result depends on the governing documents, applicable law, transaction and tax year. Scheduling a consultation does not extend a deadline.

Does a Partial Equity Redemption Affect the Units You Keep?

A partial redemption should be reviewed as both a completed transaction and a change to the rights that remain. The unit count is a starting point. Amendments, releases and continuing termination provisions may affect the retained award.

Build a Before and After Schedule

Assume an executive holds 120 incentive units and an agreement redeems 40. Record the 80 units retained, the transaction’s effective date, vesting status and any continuing hurdle. Then reconcile the signed agreement with the issuer’s ownership records. This is an invented illustration, not a tax valuation.

Keep older awards on separate lines. A redemption described as covering one class should be compared with language releasing claims, terminating agreements or acknowledging that all compensation has been received.

Read the Retained Rights and Release Together

Determine whether distributions, information rights, vesting and termination exceptions continue. Check whether the amendment changes the future bonus opportunity or the underlying award economics. A broad release can cover claims about earlier conduct even when some ownership remains.

The EEOC waiver guidance addresses employment-discrimination claims; equity and contract claims require their own governing-law analysis. A statement preserving units should not be treated as resolving every claim released elsewhere.

Later Departure Can Still Matter

Retained interests may remain subject to forfeiture, repurchase or other departure provisions. Identify the later event and contractual mechanism rather than relying solely on the earlier retained-unit table. Our management-equity departure guide explains that comparison.

Reconcile Tax Reporting

Separate any cash bonus from proceeds attributable to ownership. An actual partial partnership redemption requires review of distributions, basis, liabilities, allocations and remaining ownership. Publication 541 explains the relevant federal framework; sale-versus-redemption analysis addresses the transaction distinction.

Keep the executed amendment, payment records, updated ownership statement, relevant K-1s and basis records together. Review the original award under profits interests and management equity before signing a later acknowledgment that all rights have ended.

Review the Agreement Before You Sign

Schedule a $500 Tax Attorney Consultation

The fee includes up to one hour of total attorney time for review, analysis, preparation and the telephone consultation combined. Comprehensive document review, calculations, valuation work, drafting, negotiation, tax returns and ongoing representation require a separate written engagement. Identify the earliest signing, election or payment deadline when requesting the consultation.

Authorities checked October 7, 2026. General legal and tax information. The result depends on the governing documents, applicable law, transaction and tax year. Scheduling a consultation does not extend a deadline.

A Bonus Payment That Requires Surrendering Equity: What Should You Review?

A payment offered under a bonus agreement may also require the executive to transfer equity, terminate earlier awards and sign a release. The decision requires a comparison of existing rights with the new bargain, even when the company describes the units as having little current value.

Identify What the Payment Settles

Determine whether the amount is an existing bonus entitlement, a new discretionary offer, consideration for ownership, a settlement or a combination. Read the original payment conditions and every amendment. Ask which condition already existed and which condition the new agreement adds.

For covered Colorado employee compensation, earning and payment conditions require review under the agreement and wage law. The state’s commission and bonus guidance explains the earned, vested and determinable framework. A proposed settlement and an already-earned wage should not be assumed to have the same status.

List the Rights Being Surrendered

Record every award and class covered by the redemption. Look for language ending future distributions, performance vesting, qualified-termination treatment and claims related to earlier awards. Compare the proposed list with the units actually retained after earlier transactions.

Consider a Simple Hypothetical

An executive receives a $60,000 offer under a newer cash-bonus arrangement, conditioned on surrendering an older equity award. Review whether the cash is independently due, whether the older award remains outstanding, and what future economic and legal rights would end. The amount and facts are illustrative; no value or entitlement is assumed.

A Redemption Label Does Not Establish Capital Gain

Separate compensation from consideration for an actual ownership interest. Partnership-interest treatment can depend on the structure, basis, liabilities and ordinary-income components. IRS Publication 541 provides the federal partnership framework. The allocation in a contract and payroll withholding should be reconciled with the underlying rights and facts.

Review the Complete Package

Bring the bonus agreement, awards, governing agreement, amendments, prior redemption records, current ownership schedule and proposed release. Start with executive severance, redemption and release review and transaction and retention bonus conditions.

Review the Agreement Before You Sign

Schedule a $500 Tax Attorney Consultation

The fee includes up to one hour of total attorney time for review, analysis, preparation and the telephone consultation combined. Comprehensive document review, calculations, valuation work, drafting, negotiation, tax returns and ongoing representation require a separate written engagement. Identify the earliest signing, election or payment deadline when requesting the consultation.

Authorities checked October 7, 2026. General legal and tax information. The result depends on the governing documents, applicable law, transaction and tax year. Scheduling a consultation does not extend a deadline.

Form 7203: Who Must File and How It Relates to Form 1120-S

Form 7203 is filed by an S corporation shareholder with the shareholder’s own tax return when a filing requirement applies. For an individual shareholder, that generally means the Form 1040 return. It is not an attachment that the S corporation files with Form 1120-S on every shareholder’s behalf.

The form tracks stock and debt basis and helps determine the treatment of losses, distributions, and loan repayments. Philip Falco, a Denver tax attorney and CPA, coordinates these issues with S corporation tax return preparation and the owner’s individual return.

Is Form 7203 required to be filed with Form 1120-S?

No. The corporation files Form 1120-S and provides Schedule K-1 information to shareholders. A shareholder uses that information, together with their own basis records, to determine whether Form 7203 must accompany their return. The form itself states that it is attached to the shareholder’s tax return. See IRS Form 7203.

This distinction is especially important when different professionals prepare the corporation’s and owner’s returns. The preparers need to coordinate the information, but the filing obligations remain separate.

Who must file Form 7203?

The IRS instructions identify four filing triggers for an S corporation shareholder:

  • Claiming a deduction for the shareholder’s share of an aggregate loss, including a loss previously limited by basis;
  • Receiving a non-dividend distribution;
  • Disposing of stock, whether or not gain is recognized; or
  • Receiving repayment of a loan made to the S corporation.

Receiving a Schedule K-1, by itself, is not a substitute for checking those triggers. Do not assume the form is unnecessary merely because the business is profitable or because an owner expects a distribution to be tax-free.

Must you maintain basis in a year when filing is not required?

Basis remains important even in a year with no filing trigger. The IRS says it may be beneficial to complete and retain Form 7203 in those years so basis is consistently maintained. Keeping the calculation in the records is different from saying that every shareholder must file the form every year.

An incomplete history can become a problem when a later year involves losses, distributions, a stock sale, or repayment of shareholder debt. Reconstructing several years at that point can require old returns, K-1s, contribution records, and loan documentation.

Stock basis and debt basis answer different questions

Stock basis reflects the shareholder’s investment and applicable adjustments over time. Debt basis concerns qualifying indebtedness of the corporation to the shareholder. They are tracked separately, and sufficient debt basis does not automatically make a distribution tax-free.

A guarantee of the corporation’s bank debt does not, by itself, create shareholder debt basis. The IRS instructions discuss the different treatment when a guarantor actually makes a payment. Review how an advance or payment was documented instead of relying solely on a bookkeeping label.

A simple stock-basis example

For illustration, assume a shareholder begins with $20,000 of stock basis, contributes $5,000, is allocated $10,000 of income, and receives an $8,000 non-dividend distribution. With no other adjustments, ending stock basis is $27,000. Actual calculations must account for the applicable ordering rules and all relevant transactions.

Why the K-1 and the balance sheet may not be enough

A current K-1 reports the year’s items; the shareholder’s starting basis may depend on transactions from earlier years or the way stock was acquired. The business’s book equity is not necessarily the shareholder’s tax basis.

For example, an owner may have contributed cash, received distributions, and used losses across several years. Looking only at the latest K-1 can omit the history needed for the current calculation. A useful workpaper traces the opening balance, relevant changes, and closing balance, with support for each.

Basis is only one limit on deducting an S corporation loss

A loss allowed by the basis calculation can still be affected by other rules, including at-risk, passive-activity, or excess-business-loss limitations. The IRS stock and debt basis guidance explains why these limitations need to be considered separately.

Records to provide with the S corporation return

  • Current and prior K-1s, Forms 7203, and suspended-loss schedules;
  • Records of stock purchases, contributions, gifts, inheritances, or sales;
  • Distribution details and the dates of ownership changes;
  • Shareholder loan documents, advances, repayments, and guarantee payments; and
  • The corporation’s financial statements and the shareholder’s prior tax returns.

Our Denver tax preparation services coordinate business and owner reporting. Related Colorado obligations are discussed in our DR 0106 filing guide.

Schedule a $500 Tax Attorney Consultation to discuss basis records and coordinated return preparation. The fee covers up to one hour of total attorney time, including review, analysis, preparation, and the telephone consultation. Return preparation requires a separate engagement.

General information; filing requirements and tax treatment depend on the shareholder’s transactions and circumstances.

S Corp 1120S and Partnership 1065 Colorado filing Requirement DR 0106

S Corps 1120S & Partnerships 1065 that meet Colorado Revised Statute 39-22-301(1) must file Colorado DR 0106. If your S Corp or Partnership was organized or commercially domiciled in Colorado, among others, then it must file DR 0106. CRS 38-22-201(1).

The DR0106 effectively captures Colorado state income tax on nonresident shareholders and partners. In addition, it enables taxpayers who wish to use the SALT Parity Act.

Colorado House Bill 23-1277, “CONCERNING THE FILING OF INCOME TAX RETURNS BY BUSINESS ENTITIES” made changes to CRS 39-22-601. The good news is that pursuant to CRS 39-22-302, “An S corporation shall not be subject to taxation under this article.” This is the flow-through S Corp tax concept written into Colorado law.

However, nonresident shareholders are subject to Colorado income tax. In the instance where an S Corp or Partnership has Colorado nonresident shareholders it generally must pay income tax on their behalf. They could also file an agreement.

Pursuant to CRS 39-5-102, county assessors must beam a list of nonresident property owners to the Colorado Department of Revenue (CDR). If the nonresident is running a short term rental, you could be sure they will get notice from the CDR. If the nonresident is a shareholder of an S Corp, the CDR can then file a DR 0106 and assess tax. There is also a hefty penalty for nonpayment of Colorado tax that surely will be applied.

There is a new focus to tax nonresidents of Colorado income. This focus is embodied in the changes to 39-22-601.

Colorado DR 0106 reporting should be coordinated with the federal return. We prepare both S corporation Form 1120-S returns and partnership Form 1065 returns, including related Colorado reporting.

If you need advice on a Colorado filing obligation before engaging a return preparer, Start your $500 tax attorney consultation. The $500 consultation includes up to one hour of total attorney time, including document review and a telephone call. Written opinions or memoranda, tax return preparation, and representation require a separate engagement.

Colorado pass-through entity reporting is one part of broader business tax preparation, which should coordinate the federal entity return, Colorado filings, shareholder or partner reporting, and the owner’s individual return.

Missing IRS Refund

If you did not receive IRS refunds, check the refund status here: https://www.irs.gov/wheres-my-refund.

If you are sure about the missing refund, you need to start a refund trace by calling and speaking to an IRS agent 800-829-1040. You could also fill out IRS form 3911. You could fax the form to the appropriate number here: https://www.irs.gov/forms-pubs/about-form-3911.

You should place an identity protection pin on your file with an agent.

Form 1065 and 1120-S Filing Deadlines and Late Filing Penalties

Updated September 12, 2026. Covers calendar-year 2025 returns filed in 2026.

For calendar-year 2025 partnership and S corporation returns, the regular federal filing deadline was March 16, 2026. A timely, valid extension generally moves the deadline to September 15, 2026. The March date shifts because March 15 falls on a Sunday. Fiscal-year businesses and taxpayers covered by special relief may have different deadlines. See the IRS instructions for Form 1065 and Form 1120-S.

Missing the deadline can create a substantial penalty even when the business owes no federal income tax. Before calculating exposure, establish the return year, whether an extension was valid, and how many people held ownership interests during the year.

When are partnership and S corporation returns due?

Federal return for calendar year 2025 Regular filing deadline Extended filing deadline with a timely, valid extension
Partnership Form 1065 March 16, 2026 September 15, 2026
S corporation Form 1120-S March 16, 2026 September 15, 2026

For a fiscal-year entity, the general deadline is the 15th day of the third month after its tax year ends, subject to applicable exceptions. Do not use the calendar-year dates without confirming the business’s tax year. IRS Form 1065 instructions, IRS Form 1120-S instructions.

How does Form 7004 extend the deadline?

Most partnerships and S corporations use Form 7004 to request an automatic six-month filing extension. It generally must be filed by the original return deadline. Keep proof of timely filing and, for an electronic submission, the acceptance acknowledgment.

A business extension does not extend an owner’s individual return. An owner’s personal extension likewise does not extend the business return. Filing Form 7004 also does not extend the time to pay tax that is due. IRS Form 7004 instructions.

September 15 is normally the end of the regular extension for a calendar-year entity. However, an IRS disaster postponement or other applicable special relief can change the deadline. Check the relief announcement’s covered taxpayers, locations, and filing periods before relying on a later date. IRS disaster tax relief.

How much is the late-filing penalty?

For returns required to be filed in 2026, the basic federal late-filing penalty is generally $255 per partner or shareholder for each month or part of a month, for up to 12 months. Count everyone who was a partner or shareholder at any time during the tax year, rather than just the owners remaining at year-end. The amount is adjusted for inflation, so use the rate applicable to the return’s required filing year. IRS failure-to-file penalty guidance.

For the basic penalty, the calculation is:

$255 × number of partners or shareholders × months or partial months late, up to 12.

Owners during the tax year 1 penalty month 2 penalty months 12 penalty months
2 $510 $1,020 $6,120
4 $1,020 $2,040 $12,240

These examples exclude other penalties and assume no relief applies. An S corporation owing tax can face additional tax-based penalties. Missing or incorrect Schedules K-1 can also create separate exposure. IRS Form 1120-S instructions.

Does October 1 start a second penalty month?

No. Penalty months are measured from the applicable due date, rather than by counting calendar months touched by the delay.

For a return validly extended to September 15, 2026, the first penalty month runs September 16 through October 15. Filing on October 2 falls within that first period. With four owners, the basic penalty would therefore be $1,020, assuming no special relief or other penalties. Filing on October 16 enters a second penalty month and increases that amount to $2,040. These examples apply the IRS’s due-date-based method for counting penalty months. IRS penalty computation guidance.

Can a penalty apply when no tax is owed?

Yes. The partnership filing penalty concerns the required information return and can apply even without entity-level income tax. An incomplete return can also trigger a penalty. IRS Form 1065 instructions.

S corporations generally pass income and other tax items through to shareholders, but some owe entity-level taxes, including certain built-in gains taxes. Saying that no tax is ever due with Form 1120-S would be inaccurate. IRS Form 1120-S instructions.

What should you do after missing the deadline?

  1. Verify the filing history. Locate the return, extension, electronic acceptance records, and any IRS notices.
  2. Finish the required filing. Reconcile the books and prepare complete returns and owner schedules promptly.
  3. Check the penalty calculation. Compare the IRS’s due date, owner count, applicable rate, and number of late months against the records.
  4. Evaluate relief. Identify the applicable relief provision and gather the evidence it requires.

Keep a dated chronology of what prevented filing and what steps the business took to resolve the problem. If a notice has arrived, preserve it and track its response deadline. For assistance with overdue filings, see our unfiled tax returns service.

Can the IRS remove the penalty?

Depending on the facts, reasonable cause may support relief. Certain small partnerships may qualify under Revenue Procedure 84-35. Having ten or fewer partners is only one condition: partner eligibility, consistent proportional allocations, timely owner reporting, and the other IRS requirements must also be checked. This partnership provision is not an S corporation exemption. IRS CP162A notice guidance.

Administrative relief may also apply. The IRS describes a transition beginning in summer 2026 from First Time Abate to Automatic Exemption from Penalty for eligible returns, including Forms 1065 and 1120-S. Eligibility depends on the applicable period and compliance history. If a penalty was assessed, check whether relief was applied or needs to be requested. IRS administrative penalty relief.

For help evaluating a notice and supporting a request, see our tax penalty abatement service.

Colorado DR 0106 has a different deadline

The federal September deadline should not be confused with Colorado’s filing schedule. For calendar-year 2025, Colorado DR 0106 is generally due April 15, 2026, with an automatic six-month filing extension to October 15, 2026. The state extension does not extend the payment deadline. Colorado’s 2025 DR 0106 instructions.

See our separate discussion of Colorado partnership and S corporation filing requirements for the state return.

Help with a partnership or S corporation return

If your business needs a return prepared, review our Form 1065 partnership tax services or Form 1120-S S corporation tax services. If you received a penalty notice, bring the notice, extension confirmation, filed return, and ownership history to a consultation so the filing obligation and potential relief can be evaluated together.

Employment Tax Audit – 941, 940, W2. Footnote on IRS downsizing

We recently represented several taxpayers in employment tax audits stemming from discrepancies between Forms 941 and W-2.

Employment tax should have zero errors: quarterly 941s should match year-end W-2s and the W-3. The 940 should also match. Finally, the income tax return (1040 schedule C, 1120S, 1065, 1120) should match as far as wages, payroll tax. If any of these are inconsistent, a payroll tax audit could follow suit.

Typically there are gaps in 941s filed. There might be gaps in 941 payments. In other words, if the tax shown in the W-2 plus the employer side (15.3 percent) does not match deposits, an audit could be triggered.

Once an audit is triggered, it is more expansive in scope and years. The income tax return is reviewed for irregularities, and the number of years reviewed is expanded. In addition, state issues are reviewed such as state unemployment tax payment, rate. Employee benefits are reviewed such as health insurance, pension/profit sharing plans, automobile use, allowances, reimbursements.

Employee records are checked triggering potential illegal alien employment audit such as with employee Forms I-9 and W-4. Cash disbursements are checked, vendor payments, 1099s. All books and records can be checked, including accounting software. These audit exams are handled by IRS Revenue Agents with vast power.

It has been my recent experience that the IRS downsizing efforts have taken a toll. I have heard repeatedly from various agents about the stress and effects throughout the entire country. I recently heard of an effort of 40% downsizing. Many agents do not know if they can complete an audit because they might be terminated. I just thought it was interesting to note the real time effect.

Payroll filings should be reconciled with the underlying business income-tax return before inconsistencies attract IRS attention. Our tax compliance review can examine returns, payroll filings, information returns, and supporting records for discrepancies before an examination begins.

Guilty until Proven Innocent? Tax Court Burden of Proof

Who has the upper hand in Tax Court, the IRS or the Taxpayer? You decide.

You are considering filing a petition with the United States Tax Court perhaps regarding your Notice of Deficiency post IRS audit. Here are a few rules of play to be aware of.

The IRS’s determinations in a notice of deficiency are generally presumed correct, and taxpayers bear the burden of proving them erroneous. Rule 142(a); Welch v. Helvering, 290 U.S. 111, 115 (1933). This puts the main hurdle on the Taxpayer. To put it in common terms, the Taxpayer is presumed guilty, not innocent (these are civil matters, not criminal so this is an analogy). Walking into Tax Court, Taxpayer must prove the IRS’s position is wrong.

All is not hopeless. However, if a taxpayer produces credible evidence with respect to one or more factual issues relevant to the taxpayer’s tax liability, the burden of proof may shift to the IRS as to that issue or issues. § 7491(a)(1). Likewise, the IRS’s determination does not receive a presumption of correctness if the determination is shown to be arbitrary and capricious. Helvering v. Taylor, 293 U.S. 507, 514 (1935); Cohen v. Commissioner, 266 F.2d 5, 11 (9th Cir. 1959), remanding T.C. Memo. 1957-172. Also, the IRS bears the burden of proving new matters asserted in its answer. See Rule 142(a).

Tax Court proceedings are conducted in accordance with the Federal Rules of Evidence. § 7453; Rule 143(a).

Section 7491(a)(1) provides that if, in any court proceeding, a taxpayer introduces credible evidence with respect to any factual issue relevant to ascertaining the liability of the taxpayer for any tax imposed by subtitle A or B, the IRS shall have the burden of proof with respect to that issue. See Higbee v. Commissioner, 116 T.C. 438, 440–41 (2001). For the burden to be placed on the IRS under this section, however, the taxpayer must demonstrate that he has: (1) complied with the requirements under the Code to substantiate any item, (2) maintained all records required under the Code, and (3) cooperated with reasonable requests by the Secretary for witnesses, information, documents, meetings, and interviews. See § 7491(a)(2); Higbee, 116 T.C. at 440–41.

IRS Pre-Audit Investigations

Audit “Flags” – Straight from the Internal Revenue Manual

Large Unusual Questionable Items (LUQs)

The definition of a large, unusual, or questionable item will depend on the examiner’s perception of the return as a whole and the separate items that comprise the return. Some factors to be considered when identifying LUQs are:

  1. Comparative size of the item — an expense item of $6,000.00 with total expenses of $30,000.00 would be a large item; however, if total expenses are $300,000.00, the item would not be generally considered a large item.
  2. Absolute size of the item — despite the comparability factor, size by itself may be significant. For example, a $50,000 item may be significant even though it represents a small percentage of taxable income.
  3. Inherent character of the item — although the amount of an item may be insignificant, the nature of the item may be significant; e.g., airplane expenses claimed on a plumber’s Schedule C.
  4. Evidence of intent to mislead — this may include missing schedules, incomplete schedules, misclassified entries, or obviously incorrect items on the return.
  5. Beneficial effect of the manner in which an item is reported — expenses claimed on a business schedule rather than claimed as an itemized deduction.
  6. Relationship to other items — incomplete transactions identified on the tax return. For example, the taxpayer reported sales of stock but no dividend income.
  7. Whipsaw issues — occur when there is a transaction between two parties and characteristics of the transaction will benefit one party and harm the other. Examples include alimony vs. child support, sale vs. rental/royalty, employee vs. independent contractor, gift vs. income.
  8. Missing items — consideration should be given to items which are not shown on the return but would normally appear on the returns of similar taxpayers. This applies not only to the examination of income, but also to expenses, deductions, etc., that would result in tax changes favorable to the taxpayer.

The foregoing is an excerpt from the Internal Revenue Manual.  These are some of the recommended procedures to IRS Agents when doing background work before a taxpayer is contacted.

The tax return would have been flagged already.  It is now in the hands of the scrutinizing IRS Agent.  These are some of the items the agent will look at closely before contacting the taxpayer.

Click here to read about IRS Audits including IRS letters.

Excerpt from Publication 1, Taxpayer Rights

The process of selecting a return for examination usually begins in one of two ways. First, we use computer programs to identify returns that may have incorrect amounts. These programs may be based on information returns, such as Forms 1099 and W-2, on studies of past examinations, or on certain issues identified by compliance projects. Second, we use information from outside sources that indicates that a return may have incorrect amounts. These sources may include newspapers, public records, and individuals. If we determine that the information is accurate and reliable, we may use it to select a return for examination.

The same issues an examiner looks for can often be identified before an audit. Our tax compliance review examines filed returns and related records for inconsistencies, unusual items, missing information, and other potential examination exposure.

Judge Learned Hand on Taxes

By Philip Falco, Attorney, CPA. In an opinion penned in 1934, Judge Learned Hand endorsed the use of tax planning.  In Helvering v. Gregory, 69 F.2d 809, Judge Learned Hand wrote: “Anyone may arrange his affairs so that his taxes shall be as low as possible; he is not bound to choose that pattern which best pays the treasury. There is not even a patriotic duty to increase one’s taxes. Over and over again the Courts have said that there is nothing sinister in so arranging affairs as to keep taxes as low as possible. Everyone does it, rich and poor alike and all do right, for nobody owes any public duty to pay more than the law demands.”

To put it another way, there is no patriotic duty to pay more tax than the least tax payable under the tax code. This is the essence of tax planning in a nutshell.

A solid understanding of the tax code is what it takes to navigate to the least tax payable under the tax law.