Employment Tax Audit – 941, 940, W2. Footnote on IRS downsizing

We recently represented several taxpayers in employment tax audits stemming from discrepancies between Forms 941 and W-2.

Employment tax should have zero errors: quarterly 941s should match year-end W-2s and the W-3. The 940 should also match. Finally, the income tax return (1040 schedule C, 1120S, 1065, 1120) should match as far as wages, payroll tax. If any of these are inconsistent, a payroll tax audit could follow suit.

Typically there are gaps in 941s filed. There might be gaps in 941 payments. In other words, if the tax shown in the W-2 plus the employer side (15.3 percent) does not match deposits, an audit could be triggered.

Once an audit is triggered, it is more expansive in scope and years. The income tax return is reviewed for irregularities, and the number of years reviewed is expanded. In addition, state issues are reviewed such as state unemployment tax payment, rate. Employee benefits are reviewed such as health insurance, pension/profit sharing plans, automobile use, allowances, reimbursements.

Employee records are checked triggering potential illegal alien employment audit such as with employee Forms I-9 and W-4. Cash disbursements are checked, vendor payments, 1099s. All books and records can be checked, including accounting software. These audit exams are handled by IRS Revenue Agents with vast power.

It has been my recent experience that the IRS downsizing efforts have taken a toll. I have heard repeatedly from various agents about the stress and effects throughout the entire country. I recently heard of an effort of 40% downsizing. Many agents do not know if they can complete an audit because they might be terminated. I just thought it was interesting to note the real time effect.

Payroll filings should be reconciled with the underlying business income-tax return before inconsistencies attract IRS attention. Our tax compliance review can examine returns, payroll filings, information returns, and supporting records for discrepancies before an examination begins.

IRS Tax Preparer Audit Representation

An IRS tax preparer audit examines the preparer’s compliance obligations, which can differ from the issues in an individual client’s audit. Philip Falco, Attorney & CPA, has represented tax preparers selected for examination under the IRS paid preparer due diligence program. Representation can address both the supporting records and the response to the examiner.

If you received a letter or examination request, gather the complete notice and its attachments before responding. Identify the tax years, returns, requested records, and response date so the scope of the examination can be reviewed.

What Does an IRS Tax Preparer Audit Examine?

A due diligence examination may focus on how you determined eligibility for specified tax credits or head-of-household filing status, what questions you asked, and which records you kept. The IRS describes these obligations in its tax preparer due diligence rules.

The particular request may involve client interviews, dependents, income and expenses, or inconsistencies in information supplied by clients. Review the actual examination letter rather than assuming that every preparer audit has the same scope.

Form 8867 and Due Diligence

Form 8867, Paid Preparer’s Due Diligence Checklist, concerns specified credits and head-of-household filing status. Completing a checklist is part of the process; the underlying questions, computations, and documentation also matter.

The IRS knowledge and recordkeeping guidance explains the need for reasonable follow-up when information appears incorrect, inconsistent, or incomplete. A useful response connects the preparer’s work to the records available for each return under review.

Records to Assemble Before Responding

  • The IRS letter, attachments, prior correspondence, and any proposed examination findings.
  • The returns identified in the request and associated Forms 8867 and credit worksheets.
  • Client interview notes, follow-up questions and answers, and records of how, when, and from whom information was obtained.
  • Copies of client documents relied upon in preparing the returns.
  • Relevant preparation procedures, staff training materials, and review records.

Preserve existing records and identify gaps accurately. Do not reconstruct a file in a way that makes a later explanation appear to be a contemporaneous note.

Responding to the Examiner

Start by matching each request to the relevant return, client file, and supporting explanation. Separate records that exist from items requiring clarification. Review the scope and response date before producing documents or agreeing to an interview.

An attorney and CPA can help evaluate the request, organize the accounting evidence, explain disputed issues, and communicate with the IRS under the agreed representation scope. An examination does not by itself establish that a preparer violated a requirement.

Proposed Penalties and Representation Scope

Due diligence failures can result in preparer penalties under Internal Revenue Code section 6695(g). The issues, applicable tax years, and facts determine the potential exposure and response. If the examination raises concerns about intentional conduct, discuss those concerns with counsel before responding.

A consultation can help identify the immediate issues and records needed. Ongoing examination work, document preparation, correspondence, and representation require a separate engagement.

Discuss Your Tax Preparer Audit

Schedule a $500 Tax Attorney Consultation. The fee includes up to one hour of total attorney time for document review, analysis, preparation, and the telephone consultation combined. Bring the IRS notice and any approaching response dates.

Gotcha: IRS Tax Return Proposed Changes CP2000 – Omitted 1099

We have handled the following situation many times so I figured I would write a post about it. This is very common.

The bad news. Taxpayer receives CP2000 from the IRS, which is IRS’s proposed changes to the 1040 tax return. IRS has a before (shown on return) and after column (as corrected by the IRS). Typically taxpayer has forgotten to include a 1099, such as a 1099-S from the sale of a home, or perhaps a 1099-MISC as to schedule C income.

Taxpayer is scratching his/her head thinking well no tax is owed since the gain from the sale of my home was less than the principal residence tax exclusion of $250,000 or $500,000 for married couples. True but the IRS wants to see the steps.

Also, you might think that the 1099-MISC income was included in schedule C gross income. True but the IRS wants to see the 1099 tied to gross income and reported with the return. In truth, IRS proposed change would double include that 1099 income since it was already included on your schedule C, but the IRS does not know that.

The IRS does not give taxpayers the benefit of the doubt. Taxpayers must apply appropriate tax rules in their return. The IRS assumes worst case scenario when proposing changes, which must then be disproved by the taxpayer. Give us a call to handle this for you.

If you go at it alone, you would have to correct the return and provide the correct documentation to the IRS. If the IRS accepts your corrections, the assessment will be adjusted correctly and you win, or at least set the record straight.

IRS Pre-Audit Investigations

Audit “Flags” – Straight from the Internal Revenue Manual

Large Unusual Questionable Items (LUQs)

The definition of a large, unusual, or questionable item will depend on the examiner’s perception of the return as a whole and the separate items that comprise the return. Some factors to be considered when identifying LUQs are:

  1. Comparative size of the item — an expense item of $6,000.00 with total expenses of $30,000.00 would be a large item; however, if total expenses are $300,000.00, the item would not be generally considered a large item.
  2. Absolute size of the item — despite the comparability factor, size by itself may be significant. For example, a $50,000 item may be significant even though it represents a small percentage of taxable income.
  3. Inherent character of the item — although the amount of an item may be insignificant, the nature of the item may be significant; e.g., airplane expenses claimed on a plumber’s Schedule C.
  4. Evidence of intent to mislead — this may include missing schedules, incomplete schedules, misclassified entries, or obviously incorrect items on the return.
  5. Beneficial effect of the manner in which an item is reported — expenses claimed on a business schedule rather than claimed as an itemized deduction.
  6. Relationship to other items — incomplete transactions identified on the tax return. For example, the taxpayer reported sales of stock but no dividend income.
  7. Whipsaw issues — occur when there is a transaction between two parties and characteristics of the transaction will benefit one party and harm the other. Examples include alimony vs. child support, sale vs. rental/royalty, employee vs. independent contractor, gift vs. income.
  8. Missing items — consideration should be given to items which are not shown on the return but would normally appear on the returns of similar taxpayers. This applies not only to the examination of income, but also to expenses, deductions, etc., that would result in tax changes favorable to the taxpayer.

The foregoing is an excerpt from the Internal Revenue Manual.  These are some of the recommended procedures to IRS Agents when doing background work before a taxpayer is contacted.

The tax return would have been flagged already.  It is now in the hands of the scrutinizing IRS Agent.  These are some of the items the agent will look at closely before contacting the taxpayer.

Click here to read about IRS Audits including IRS letters.

Excerpt from Publication 1, Taxpayer Rights

The process of selecting a return for examination usually begins in one of two ways. First, we use computer programs to identify returns that may have incorrect amounts. These programs may be based on information returns, such as Forms 1099 and W-2, on studies of past examinations, or on certain issues identified by compliance projects. Second, we use information from outside sources that indicates that a return may have incorrect amounts. These sources may include newspapers, public records, and individuals. If we determine that the information is accurate and reliable, we may use it to select a return for examination.

The same issues an examiner looks for can often be identified before an audit. Our tax compliance review examines filed returns and related records for inconsistencies, unusual items, missing information, and other potential examination exposure.