S Corp Requirements (disproportionate distributions)

S Corporations can only have one class of stock. An argument can be unsuccessfully made that uneven de facto distributions to shareholders would be more than one class of stock. However, so long as the corporate documents call for even distributions all is ok even if uneven distributions subsequently occur.

The legal basis for this is found in the regulations: the regulation tells the IRS to focus on shareholder rights under a corporation’s governing documents, not what shareholders actually do. The regulation states that uneven distributions don’t mean that the corporation has more than one class of stock. Treas. Reg. § 1.1361-1(l)(2) (“[A] corporation is not treated as having more than one class of stock so long as the governing provisions provide for identical distribution and liquidation rights . . . .”).

Taking a step back, the first rule is that shareholders have to choose to be taxed as an S corporation. Shareholders do so by filling out a Form 2553, Election by a Small Business Corporation, that they file with the IRS. See Treas. Reg. § 1.1362-6(a)(2)(i). Once the IRS approves, the election remains effective indefinitely. § 1362(c); see Mourad v. Commissioner, 121 T.C. 1, 4 (2003), aff’d, 387 F.3d 27 (1st Cir. 2004).

A great many small and medium-sized businesses elect S corporation status because the Code affords them special treatment—income earned by the corporation escapes corporate-level taxation. Mourad, 121 T.C. at 3; see §§ 1363, 1366. That income is instead “passed through” to its shareholders pro rata. See §§ 1363, 1366. But electing to be an S corporation is not enough. The Code has several other requirements. These include having no more than 100 shareholders, having only shareholders who are individuals—or certain trusts or nonprofits—and not having any nonresident alien shareholders. § 1361(b)(1). The parties don’t dispute that Schricker met these requirements.

There’s one other requirement. Section 1361(b)(1)(D) allows a corporation to be an S corporation only if it has no more than one class of stock. What does that mean? Section 1361 doesn’t say, but we know that run-of-the-mill debt isn’t a second class of stock. § 1361(c)(5)(A). And neither are differences in common-stock voting rights. § 1361(c)(4).

The regulation gives us a little more help. It generally treats a corporation as having only one class of stock so long as all the shares confer equal rights to dividends and liquidation proceeds. Treas. Reg. § 1.1361-1(l)(1) (“[A] corporation is treated as having only one class of stock if all outstanding shares of stock of the corporation confer identical rights to distribution and liquidation proceeds”).

The regulation also tells us to determine whether stock confers identical rights to distributions and liquidation proceeds based on the corporation’s governing provisions. Id. subpara. (2)(i). These are
documents like a corporate charter, articles of incorporation, and bylaws. Id. The IRS has said it won’t treat any disproportionate distributions made by a corporation as violating the one-class-of-stock requirement if the governing provisions provide for identical rights. Rev. Proc. 2022-19, § 3.02, 2022-41 I.R.B. 282, 286.

As you can see this topic is a Pandora’s box. Luckily we have some common-sense regulations to pave the way forward, thank you Department of Treasury 🙂

Distribution issues should also be reviewed as part of S corporation tax return preparation, because distributions interact with shareholder basis, Schedule K-1 reporting, and the shareholder’s Form 1040.

CFO and Board Advisory for Companies and Investment Funds

Philip Falco, Attorney and CPA, advises business owners, executives, boards, and investment managers on financial, tax, and legal matters. Engagements can focus on a specific issue, such as following up on internal audit findings or evaluating the tax implications of an entity structure, or provide ongoing advisory support.

Who This Advisory Service Is For

  • Private equity firms and portfolio companies. Review portfolio-company reporting and controls, evaluate tax and entity-structure questions, and help management turn audit findings into changes in policy and practice.
  • Hedge funds and other investment managers. Advise on management-company tax and entity structure, internal financial controls, and issues that call for coordination with fund administrators, auditors, and outside counsel.
  • Mid-sized and large companies. Support executives, boards, and audit committees with internal audit follow-up, fraud prevention and detection, and review of financial practices that may create legal exposure.
  • Closely held and growing businesses. Advise owners on tax planning and compliance, entity structure, and financial reporting as the business grows.

Financial Reporting, Tax and Legal Coordination

  • Review financial reporting alongside the business’s tax and legal structure.
  • Identify compliance and documentation issues that need follow-up with the company’s existing advisers.
  • Discuss internal-review recommendations, related policies, and controls intended to address fraud and legal exposure.
  • Connect ownership and business decisions with the appropriate tax, accounting, and legal work.

The engagement defines the actual advisory work and the responsibilities of the firm and the company’s existing advisers.

Formal CFO and Board Appointments

Advisory engagements have a defined scope. A formal appointment as CFO, another officer, or a director requires a separate written agreement and appropriate company approval.

Records to Bring to an Initial Review

Start with available financial statements, budgets or internal reports, prior tax returns, payroll summaries, formation documents, and an ownership chart. Include relevant board or management materials and any internal-review recommendations you want addressed. Identify missing records and the business decision or deadline that prompted the review.

Define the Engagement and Next Steps

  1. Identify the business need. Explain the reporting, compliance, governance, or transaction issue and who is currently responsible for it.
  2. Review the available records. Identify gaps, existing advisers, and work that may need a separate specialist engagement.
  3. Agree on scope. Confirm the advisory responsibilities, work covered, timing, fees, and any ongoing coordination. A formal appointment requires its own agreement.

The initial consultation is separate from ongoing advisory work, return preparation, and any formal CFO or board role.

Discuss CFO and Board Advisory

Schedule a $500 Tax Attorney Consultation. The fee includes up to one hour of total attorney time for document review, analysis, preparation, and the telephone consultation combined. Tax-return preparation, filings, and representation require a separate engagement.

Ongoing CFO and advisory work is most effective when financial reporting, payroll, tax planning, and annual returns are coordinated. Our business tax preparation service handles that annual filing component for closely held businesses and their owners.

Businesses that need recurring tax guidance without a full CFO engagement may also use our year-round tax advisory service for proactive tax planning and ongoing coordination throughout the year.