LLC Member Buyout Tax Consequences: Sale vs. Redemption

An LLC member buyout can be taxed differently depending on whether another owner buys the interest or the LLC itself redeems it. The price is only part of the calculation. Outside basis, partnership debt, payment terms, and the business’s assets can change both the amount and character of the departing member’s income or loss.

This guide applies to LLCs taxed as partnerships. Confirm tax classification before using partnership rules for an LLC that has elected corporate treatment.

For contractual pricing and notice requirements, see how an operating agreement sets an LLC buyout price.

Start With Who Pays and Who Acquires the Interest

Two common structures for an LLC member buyout
IssueSale to another personRedemption by the LLC
TransactionA remaining member or outside buyer acquires the interest.The partnership liquidates the departing member’s interest.
Starting rules§§741 and 751; debt relief enters the sale calculation.§§731 and 736, with other distribution rules as applicable.
LossGenerally capital, except for the §751 portion and other applicable rules.A liquidating loss is allowed only under specified conditions.
Basis adjustmentPotential §743(b) adjustment for the buyer.Potential §734(b) adjustment to remaining partnership property.

These are starting points, not interchangeable formulas. A multistep deal, a buyout leaving one owner, or a payment partly for services requires additional analysis.

Selling the Interest: Proceeds, Debt Relief, and Basis

A sale generally produces gain or loss by comparing the amount realized with adjusted outside basis. The amount realized can include both the cash or property received and relief from partnership liabilities. Determine outside basis separately from the K-1 capital account.

Example: The Check Is Not the Entire Sale Price for Tax Purposes

Assume a member receives $80,000 cash and is relieved of a $30,000 share of partnership liabilities. The member’s adjusted outside basis is $70,000, including the liability allocation, immediately before sale. Ignoring selling costs and other adjustments, the total amount realized is $110,000 and total gain is $40,000.

The entire $40,000 is not necessarily capital gain. The partnership must provide the asset information needed to determine the §751 ordinary-income portion.

“Hot assets” is shorthand for unrealized receivables and inventory covered by §751. Unrealized receivables can include specified depreciation-recapture amounts. A sale can therefore create ordinary income even when the overall investment has performed poorly. See IRS Publication 541 and IRC §751.

An LLC Redemption Is Not Automatically a Capital Sale

When the partnership pays a retiring partner, §736 can distinguish payments for the partner’s interest in partnership property from payments treated as a distributive share or guaranteed payment. The treatment of goodwill and unrealized receivables depends on the statutory conditions and the agreement. Avoid assigning one tax label to every dollar of a retirement package.

For amounts treated as distributions, §731 generally recognizes gain when money, including applicable deemed money, exceeds outside basis. A loss generally requires liquidation of the entire interest and a distribution consisting only of money, unrealized receivables, and inventory. Distributions of other property may carry basis into that property instead of generating an immediate loss.

Debt changes also matter here. Read how partnership liability relief affects an exit before comparing cash-only proposals.

When a buyout follows a real estate disposition, see our guide to partnership 1031 exchanges when one owner wants cash for how the exchange, gain allocation, and redemption fit together.

Payment Terms and the Buyer’s Position Matter

Installment payments can spread recognition of qualifying gain, but the ordinary-income portion attributable to unrealized receivables and inventory generally is reported in the year of sale. Interest, contingent consideration, and liability relief need separate treatment. Installment reporting can also affect the timing of suspended passive-loss deductions.

The buyer’s basis in the acquired interest is not automatically an adjustment to the partnership’s basis in its assets. A §754 election may permit a §743(b) adjustment on a transfer or a §734(b) adjustment after a distribution; some adjustments are mandatory under the substantial-loss rules. Determine eligibility, valuation, allocation, and timing rather than assuming an election always helps.

If a buyout leaves a formerly multi-member LLC with one owner, continued state-law existence does not necessarily mean continued partnership status for federal tax purposes. Revenue Ruling 99-6 addresses certain transactions in which a partnership becomes owned by one person.

For investment-fund owners and managers, see hedge fund partner buyout taxation for fund-versus-management-company distinctions, carried interests, and a multi-year installment example.

Resolve These Issues Before Signing

  1. Structure: identify the actual buyer, payer, and interest transferred.
  2. Basis: update the departing member’s basis through the transaction date.
  3. Liabilities: reconcile tax allocations, guarantees, indemnities, and lender releases.
  4. Asset character: obtain §751 and recapture information.
  5. Payments: separate purchase price, retirement payments, services, interest, and any restrictive-covenant allocation as applicable.
  6. Year of exit: coordinate allocations, distributions, and final reporting.
  7. Remaining owners: address ownership percentages, partnership continuation, and possible basis elections.

Our business purchase and sale services coordinate transaction documents and tax consequences. For an exit with no consideration, see abandonment of a partnership interest rather than assuming the buyout rules produce the same result.

For ownership-change and final K-1 reporting, our partnership tax return preparation service addresses the entity return; the departing partner’s individual tax analysis can involve a different scope and separate engagement.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is an LLC buyout always a capital gain?

No. Section 751, certain retirement payments, and separately compensated services can produce ordinary income. The legal and economic structure determines the treatment.

Can the LLC deduct the entire buyout payment?

Do not assume so. A payment for a partner’s property interest is not simply an ordinary business expense. Different components of a retirement arrangement can receive different treatment.

Does a buyout release my personal guarantee?

Not necessarily. A transfer agreement among owners may leave the lender’s rights intact. Review the guarantee and obtain any required creditor release separately from the tax analysis.

Will I receive a final K-1?

A complete exit generally requires final partner reporting, but the effective date, allocations, and any continuing payments must be reconciled. See the final K-1 checklist.

Compare the Structures Before Agreeing to a Buyout

Philip Falco, Attorney & CPA, can review the proposed terms alongside basis, liabilities, and reporting issues.

Schedule a $500 Tax Attorney Consultation

The fee includes up to one hour of total attorney time for review, analysis, preparation, and the telephone consultation combined. Drafting, return preparation, and continuing representation require a separate engagement.

General federal tax information. Transaction terms and the applicable tax year can change the result.

If a buyout accompanies a bonus, severance or release, review the executive payment and equity-surrender package separately from the partnership-interest disposition.

When the Departing Owner Also Holds Compensation Rights

A member buyout can accompany bonuses, phantom awards or a release. Review the executive’s complete compensation package and management-equity grant and vesting terms separately from the sale or redemption of the actual partnership interest.

Tax Consequences of Abandoning a Partnership or LLC Interest

Abandoning a partnership or LLC interest can sometimes produce an ordinary tax loss, but receiving no cash is not enough. The transaction must qualify as an abandonment rather than a sale or exchange, and an actual or deemed distribution can change the result. Relief from your share of partnership debt is one of the most important traps.

This guide addresses federal income tax for a partnership interest, including a membership interest in an LLC taxed as a partnership. An LLC taxed as an S corporation, a C corporation, or a disregarded entity requires a different analysis. Start by confirming the entity’s tax classification.

Planning an exit? Schedule a $500 Tax Attorney Consultation before the transaction and its documents become final.

Sale, Redemption, Abandonment, and Worthlessness

The label in an agreement does not control the federal tax result. Identify who receives the interest, what the departing owner receives, which rights end, and what happens to partnership liabilities.

Four different situations that can end a partnership investment
SituationWhat to examineTax starting point
SaleAnother person purchases the interest.Generally capital gain or loss under §741, with ordinary treatment for the §751 portion.
RedemptionThe partnership pays to liquidate the owner’s interest.Distribution and retiring-partner rules; loss recognition may be restricted.
AbandonmentThe owner permanently relinquishes the interest without consideration.Potential ordinary loss if the requirements are met and there is no actual or deemed distribution.
WorthlessnessThe interest becomes wholly worthless in a particular year.A separate factual and timing inquiry; a decline in value is insufficient.

Resigning as manager, stopping work, or ending contributions does not necessarily surrender the membership interest. For paid exits, see LLC member buyout tax consequences: sale versus redemption.

When Can an Abandonment Loss Be Ordinary?

IRS Publication 541, discussing Revenue Ruling 93-80, identifies two conditions for ordinary-loss treatment: the transaction is not a sale or exchange, and the partner receives no actual or deemed distribution. A small distribution can change the character of the entire abandonment loss, subject to applicable ordinary-income rules.

The difference matters because an individual’s net capital loss generally offsets ordinary income only up to $3,000 annually, or $1,500 if married filing separately, with carryover rules for the balance. An ordinary loss is not subject to that particular capital-loss limit. Other deduction limits may still apply.

The taxpayer must also establish a deductible loss under §165, the adjusted basis remaining in the interest, and the proper year. An agreement titled “abandonment” does not by itself prove any of these points.

Why No Cash Does Not Mean No Consideration

Under IRC §752, a decrease in a partner’s share of partnership liabilities is generally treated as a distribution of money. In a sale, liability relief is taken into account in the amount realized. The debt need not be a personal bank loan in the departing partner’s name.

Example: Same Basis, Different Debt Facts

No partnership debt: Assume a partner has $60,000 of adjusted outside basis immediately before a valid abandonment, receives nothing, and has no allocated partnership liabilities. With no sale or exchange and no actual or deemed distribution, the $60,000 loss may be ordinary, subject to the remaining loss requirements and limitations.

Debt relief: Instead assume the same $60,000 basis includes a $20,000 share of liabilities that goes away on exit. The $20,000 deemed distribution changes the analysis. Assuming a complete liquidation, no other property or payments, no §751 adjustment, and no other basis changes, the resulting $40,000 loss is generally capital rather than a $60,000 ordinary loss.

These are simplified illustrations of loss character, not predictions of the amount deductible on a particular return.

Check recourse and nonrecourse allocations, guarantees, indemnities, refinancing, and the timing of debt changes. A federal tax allocation and a lender’s legal release are different questions. Read partnership debt relief when a partner leaves.

Discuss the proposed exit before signing if the partnership has debt, you guarantee an obligation, or the paperwork includes a payment or release.

The Loss Starts With Outside Basis, Not K-1 Capital

Your capital account is not necessarily your adjusted tax basis in the partnership interest. Reconstruct outside basis through the exit date, including contributions, allocated income and losses, distributions, and changes in your share of liabilities. Do not deduct the original investment again if prior losses or distributions have already reduced basis.

A negative capital account does not mean outside basis is negative. Outside basis cannot fall below zero. A positive capital account also does not, by itself, establish a deductible loss. See partnership outside basis versus K-1 capital and our narrower discussion of promissory notes and guarantees.

Sales and Redemptions Have Their Own Rules

A sale generally starts under §741, but §751 can assign ordinary character to the portion attributable to unrealized receivables and inventory, including certain recapture items. A redemption can involve §§731 and 736; receiving property other than money, unrealized receivables, or inventory may prevent immediate recognition of a liquidating loss. Do not apply a sale calculation automatically to a redemption.

Our business purchase and sale services address transaction structure alongside the contracts and accounting.

Suspended Losses Are a Separate Question

Keep the loss on the interest separate from operating losses previously suspended on the owner’s return. Basis-limited losses under §704(d), at-risk losses under §465, and passive losses under §469 are different categories. They do not all become deductible simply because a K-1 is marked final.

Section 469(g) generally permits release of suspended passive losses on a qualifying disposition of the entire activity in a fully taxable transaction, with related-party restrictions. Activity grouping, retained interests, and installment payments can affect the outcome. An abandonment needs its own disposition analysis; ordinary-loss character alone does not resolve §469.

See suspended passive losses when leaving a partnership and IRS Publication 925. Other limits, including the excess business loss rules where applicable, may affect the final deduction.

Establish Intent, an Affirmative Act, and the Correct Year

Abandonment generally requires both an intent to abandon and an affirmative act carrying out that intent. The IRS Chief Counsel discussion in CCA 200637032 addresses these requirements and related case law. The memorandum is useful background, but it is not precedential authority.

Review the operating agreement, transfer restrictions, required notices, consents, and applicable state law. Determine whether the proposed documents actually relinquish the economic interest or merely change management rights. Identify continuing profit rights, contingent payments, obligations, or rights to future distributions.

Keep contemporaneous evidence of the decision and its implementation. Worthlessness requires evidence supporting the loss of value in the claimed year; it is not established merely by inactivity or poor financial performance. Later paperwork should not be used to invent an earlier transaction date.

Records to Gather Before an Exit Review

  • The operating or partnership agreement and amendments.
  • Draft withdrawal, sale, redemption, settlement, or release documents.
  • Prior Forms 1065 and Schedules K-1, plus a current outside-basis rollforward.
  • Capital contributions, distributions, and current-year income or loss estimates.
  • Loan agreements, liability allocations, guarantees, indemnities, and proposed releases.
  • Separate basis, at-risk, and passive-loss carryforward schedules.
  • A timeline of notices, approvals, payments, and the proposed effective date.

After the transaction, coordinate the final K-1 and exit reporting with the owner’s return. Our partnership tax return preparation service can address the entity’s exit-year return and K-1 reporting; the departing partner’s individual tax analysis can require a different scope and separate engagement.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I deduct my LLC investment if I leave for nothing?

Possibly, but first determine the LLC’s tax classification, your remaining outside basis, whether you actually relinquished the interest, and whether any actual or deemed distribution occurred. Receiving no cash does not establish an ordinary loss.

Does debt count if I never personally guaranteed it?

It can. A partner can have a share of nonrecourse partnership liabilities for tax purposes. A reduction in that allocation can affect the exit even without a personal guarantee.

Is selling my interest for $1 the same as abandonment?

No. A nominal-price transfer can still be a sale or exchange and may involve debt relief. The whole arrangement, including related parties and retained rights, needs review.

Does a final K-1 release all suspended losses?

No. The final designation documents reporting status; it does not establish that every basis, at-risk, and passive-loss requirement has been met.

Is a worthless interest automatically abandoned?

No. Worthlessness concerns value; abandonment concerns intent and action. Each requires evidence, and debt or distributions can affect loss character in either analysis.

Must I dissolve the LLC to abandon my interest?

Not necessarily. An individual owner’s exit and dissolution of the entity are different events. The agreement and governing law determine what steps are available and what obligations continue.

Review the Exit Before It Becomes Final

Philip Falco, Attorney & CPA, can evaluate the proposed transaction, basis records, liabilities, and loss issues together.

Schedule a $500 Tax Attorney Consultation

The fee includes up to one hour of total attorney time for review, analysis, preparation, and the telephone consultation combined. Return preparation, document drafting, and ongoing representation require a separate engagement.

This article provides general federal tax information. The transaction’s facts, governing documents, applicable law, and tax year determine the result.

Foreign Parent Dies Owning U.S. Investments: Estate Tax and Form 706-NA

When a parent who was neither a U.S. citizen nor U.S.-domiciled dies owning U.S. investments, the estate may have a U.S. estate-tax filing obligation. That question is separate from a beneficiary’s reporting of an inheritance.

Start With Citizenship, Domicile, and Ownership

Estate-tax residence is based on domicile, which differs from the income-tax residence tests. Determine the decedent’s status at death and what the decedent actually owned. An account title alone may not resolve marital-property rights or another person’s ownership. See the IRS Form 706-NA instructions.

A U.S. Brokerage Account Can Hold Different Types of Property

Review the holdings individually. U.S. real estate and stock of corporations organized under U.S. law generally count as U.S.-situated assets. Qualifying bank deposits and certain debt obligations may receive different treatment. A brokerage balance should not be treated as one uniform asset category. See the IRS overview of nonresident estates with U.S. assets.

When Is Form 706-NA Required?

The general filing threshold is exceeded when U.S.-situated assets at death, plus the specified gift-tax exemption and adjusted taxable gifts described in the instructions, exceed $60,000. Filing does not necessarily mean tax is due. Treaty provisions and allowable deductions require separate review.

The return is generally due nine months after death. Form 4768 provides a procedure for requesting an extension; an extension to file does not automatically extend payment. Use the forms and law applicable to the death involved, following the IRS filing instructions.

The Estate’s Return and the Heir’s Return Are Separate

A qualifying foreign bequest can require a U.S. recipient to file Form 3520 even though the receipt is not itself taxable income. Foreign-estate bequests generally use the more-than-$100,000 reporting threshold, subject to applicable aggregation rules. A foreign-trust distribution requires a different analysis. See IRS guidance on foreign gifts and bequests and our Form 3520 guide.

Build an Accounting From the Date of Death

Today’s account balance is not a substitute for a date-of-death inventory. Assemble a reconciliation showing opening ownership, subsequent income and gains or losses, expenses, distributions, and the remaining assets. Keep the surviving spouse’s pre-existing property separate from property passing through the estate.

When foreign probate remains open, ask local counsel to establish the heirs’ rights and the status of any distributions. If an heir has also died, identify the interest passing through that heir’s estate. Coordinate those findings with the U.S. tax analysis before assigning the entire current balance to one person or trust.

Documents for a Cross-Border Estate Review

  • Death certificate and citizenship and domicile history.
  • Wills, trusts, marital-property agreements, and probate records.
  • Statements around the date of death, with individual securities identified.
  • Ownership and contribution records for joint accounts.
  • Prior gift and estate filings and records of foreign taxes.
  • A ledger of later earnings, expenses, reimbursements, and distributions.

For a related question about a family living abroad with a U.S. trust, read Can a U.S. Living Trust Become a Foreign Trust?

Philip Falco, Attorney and CPA, can evaluate U.S. estate-tax and international-reporting issues alongside the estate accounting. Schedule a tax attorney consultation.

This article provides general information. Ownership, domicile, treaty provisions, and the law applicable at death can change the result.

Can a U.S. Living Trust Become a Foreign Trust?

A living trust created under U.S. state law can be a foreign trust for federal tax purposes. U.S. accounts, a U.S. mailing address, and a U.S.-citizen grantor do not resolve the question by themselves. Conversely, a trustee moving abroad does not automatically make the trust foreign.

Two Tests Determine Whether a Trust Is Domestic

The court test asks whether a U.S. court can exercise primary supervision over trust administration. The control test asks whether U.S. persons control every substantial trust decision. Both must be satisfied. Review the trust instrument, applicable law, and actual administration together. See Treasury Regulation Section 301.7701-7 and its explanatory guidance.

Overseas Administration and the Court-Test Safe Harbor

The safe harbor generally requires that the instrument not direct foreign administration, that administration actually occur exclusively in the United States, and that the trust lack a disqualifying automatic migration clause. Failing this safe harbor does not automatically fail the court test: the broader question remains whether a U.S. court has the required supervisory authority.

A U.S.-Citizen Trustee Living Abroad

A U.S. citizen generally remains a U.S. person while living abroad. Location alone therefore does not decide the control test. Examine voting arrangements, vetoes, distribution powers, and trustee-replacement authority. Analyze court supervision separately.

Domestic or Foreign Is Different From Grantor or Nongrantor

These are separate classifications. A foreign trust can have a U.S. owner under the grantor-trust rules, with income taxable to that owner and additional information returns required. Reporting investment income on Form 1040 does not itself satisfy foreign-trust reporting. See the IRS overview of foreign trust taxation and reporting.

Questions to Resolve Before Preparing Returns

  • Which version of the trust governed during each period?
  • Who could make or veto distributions, investment decisions, or trustee appointments?
  • Where were records maintained and administrative responsibilities performed?
  • What changed when a trustee moved, resigned, died, or became unable to serve?
  • Which people funded the trust, received payments, or benefited from trust property?

A useful review creates a dated history instead of applying today’s facts to every prior year. A later amendment should be examined for its actual effect and effective date; it should not be assumed to settle earlier reporting.

Which Forms May Apply?

Form 3520 addresses specified ownership and transactions involving foreign trusts. Form 3520-A generally addresses annual reporting for a foreign trust with a U.S. owner, subject to applicable exceptions. Its filing and extension rules differ from those for Form 3520. See the IRS Form 3520-A instructions.

Separate Form 8938 or FBAR analysis may also be necessary. Classifying a trust as foreign does not turn an account maintained in the United States into a foreign bank account.

What If Earlier Returns Were Missed?

Begin with classification, the relevant years, ownership, and transactions. Then evaluate the appropriate delinquent-return procedure and any related income omissions. Discuss uncertainty and any proposed protective filing with counsel; a label alone does not establish that a submission is complete or eliminates penalties.

What to Bring to a Trust Classification Consultation

  • The original trust, all amendments, and trustee appointment or resignation documents.
  • A timeline of trustee locations, responsibilities, and significant decisions.
  • Account statements, prior returns, and trust tax-identification records.
  • A transfer ledger with invoices, reimbursement records, and supporting correspondence.
  • Any prior written advice or IRS notices.

Philip Falco, Attorney and CPA, can evaluate trust classification together with the related tax filings. Schedule a tax attorney consultation. For related planning, see Wills, Trusts, and Estate Planning.

This article provides general information; the result depends on the governing documents, applicable law, and facts for the period involved.

Form 7203: Who Must File and How It Relates to Form 1120-S

Form 7203 is filed by an S corporation shareholder with the shareholder’s own tax return when a filing requirement applies. For an individual shareholder, that generally means the Form 1040 return. It is not an attachment that the S corporation files with Form 1120-S on every shareholder’s behalf.

The form tracks stock and debt basis and helps determine the treatment of losses, distributions, and loan repayments. Philip Falco, a Denver tax attorney and CPA, coordinates these issues with S corporation tax return preparation and the owner’s individual return.

Is Form 7203 required to be filed with Form 1120-S?

No. The corporation files Form 1120-S and provides Schedule K-1 information to shareholders. A shareholder uses that information, together with their own basis records, to determine whether Form 7203 must accompany their return. The form itself states that it is attached to the shareholder’s tax return. See IRS Form 7203.

This distinction is especially important when different professionals prepare the corporation’s and owner’s returns. The preparers need to coordinate the information, but the filing obligations remain separate.

Who must file Form 7203?

The IRS instructions identify four filing triggers for an S corporation shareholder:

  • Claiming a deduction for the shareholder’s share of an aggregate loss, including a loss previously limited by basis;
  • Receiving a non-dividend distribution;
  • Disposing of stock, whether or not gain is recognized; or
  • Receiving repayment of a loan made to the S corporation.

Receiving a Schedule K-1, by itself, is not a substitute for checking those triggers. Do not assume the form is unnecessary merely because the business is profitable or because an owner expects a distribution to be tax-free.

Must you maintain basis in a year when filing is not required?

Basis remains important even in a year with no filing trigger. The IRS says it may be beneficial to complete and retain Form 7203 in those years so basis is consistently maintained. Keeping the calculation in the records is different from saying that every shareholder must file the form every year.

An incomplete history can become a problem when a later year involves losses, distributions, a stock sale, or repayment of shareholder debt. Reconstructing several years at that point can require old returns, K-1s, contribution records, and loan documentation.

Stock basis and debt basis answer different questions

Stock basis reflects the shareholder’s investment and applicable adjustments over time. Debt basis concerns qualifying indebtedness of the corporation to the shareholder. They are tracked separately, and sufficient debt basis does not automatically make a distribution tax-free.

A guarantee of the corporation’s bank debt does not, by itself, create shareholder debt basis. The IRS instructions discuss the different treatment when a guarantor actually makes a payment. Review how an advance or payment was documented instead of relying solely on a bookkeeping label.

A simple stock-basis example

For illustration, assume a shareholder begins with $20,000 of stock basis, contributes $5,000, is allocated $10,000 of income, and receives an $8,000 non-dividend distribution. With no other adjustments, ending stock basis is $27,000. Actual calculations must account for the applicable ordering rules and all relevant transactions.

Why the K-1 and the balance sheet may not be enough

A current K-1 reports the year’s items; the shareholder’s starting basis may depend on transactions from earlier years or the way stock was acquired. The business’s book equity is not necessarily the shareholder’s tax basis.

For example, an owner may have contributed cash, received distributions, and used losses across several years. Looking only at the latest K-1 can omit the history needed for the current calculation. A useful workpaper traces the opening balance, relevant changes, and closing balance, with support for each.

Basis is only one limit on deducting an S corporation loss

A loss allowed by the basis calculation can still be affected by other rules, including at-risk, passive-activity, or excess-business-loss limitations. The IRS stock and debt basis guidance explains why these limitations need to be considered separately.

Records to provide with the S corporation return

  • Current and prior K-1s, Forms 7203, and suspended-loss schedules;
  • Records of stock purchases, contributions, gifts, inheritances, or sales;
  • Distribution details and the dates of ownership changes;
  • Shareholder loan documents, advances, repayments, and guarantee payments; and
  • The corporation’s financial statements and the shareholder’s prior tax returns.

Our Denver tax preparation services coordinate business and owner reporting. Related Colorado obligations are discussed in our DR 0106 filing guide.

Schedule a $500 Tax Attorney Consultation to discuss basis records and coordinated return preparation. The fee covers up to one hour of total attorney time, including review, analysis, preparation, and the telephone consultation. Return preparation requires a separate engagement.

General information; filing requirements and tax treatment depend on the shareholder’s transactions and circumstances.

S Corp 1120S and Partnership 1065 Colorado filing Requirement DR 0106

S Corps 1120S & Partnerships 1065 that meet Colorado Revised Statute 39-22-301(1) must file Colorado DR 0106. If your S Corp or Partnership was organized or commercially domiciled in Colorado, among others, then it must file DR 0106. CRS 38-22-201(1).

The DR0106 effectively captures Colorado state income tax on nonresident shareholders and partners. In addition, it enables taxpayers who wish to use the SALT Parity Act.

Colorado House Bill 23-1277, “CONCERNING THE FILING OF INCOME TAX RETURNS BY BUSINESS ENTITIES” made changes to CRS 39-22-601. The good news is that pursuant to CRS 39-22-302, “An S corporation shall not be subject to taxation under this article.” This is the flow-through S Corp tax concept written into Colorado law.

However, nonresident shareholders are subject to Colorado income tax. In the instance where an S Corp or Partnership has Colorado nonresident shareholders it generally must pay income tax on their behalf. They could also file an agreement.

Pursuant to CRS 39-5-102, county assessors must beam a list of nonresident property owners to the Colorado Department of Revenue (CDR). If the nonresident is running a short term rental, you could be sure they will get notice from the CDR. If the nonresident is a shareholder of an S Corp, the CDR can then file a DR 0106 and assess tax. There is also a hefty penalty for nonpayment of Colorado tax that surely will be applied.

There is a new focus to tax nonresidents of Colorado income. This focus is embodied in the changes to 39-22-601.

Colorado DR 0106 reporting should be coordinated with the federal return. We prepare both S corporation Form 1120-S returns and partnership Form 1065 returns, including related Colorado reporting.

If you need advice on a Colorado filing obligation before engaging a return preparer, Start your $500 tax attorney consultation. The $500 consultation includes up to one hour of total attorney time, including document review and a telephone call. Written opinions or memoranda, tax return preparation, and representation require a separate engagement.

Colorado pass-through entity reporting is one part of broader business tax preparation, which should coordinate the federal entity return, Colorado filings, shareholder or partner reporting, and the owner’s individual return.

Missing IRS Refund

If you did not receive IRS refunds, check the refund status here: https://www.irs.gov/wheres-my-refund.

If you are sure about the missing refund, you need to start a refund trace by calling and speaking to an IRS agent 800-829-1040. You could also fill out IRS form 3911. You could fax the form to the appropriate number here: https://www.irs.gov/forms-pubs/about-form-3911.

You should place an identity protection pin on your file with an agent.

The real problem with Colorado graduated tax proposal

The real problem with the Colorado graduated tax proposal is that it converts a Colorado Constitution limitation to a statutory enablement.

The proposal would permit the Colorado legislature to increase taxes on income at any time. This would be very dangerous for the State of Colorado. The proposal deletes a key provision of the Colorado Constitution that limits the Colorado legislature from changing the approximate 4.5% tax rate. The Colorado Constitution provision that would be deleted is as follows: “Any income tax law change after July 1, 1992 shall also require all taxable net income to be taxed at one rate, excluding refund tax credits or voter-approved tax credits, with no added tax or surcharge.”

Once deleted, the Colorado legislature could raise the tax rate as they see fit. The proposal entices voter approval of the key Constitution provision by proposing a tax cut on approximately 98% of Coloradans. Yes this is enticing. However, going forward the legislature could raise taxes on those 98% at any time since the key Colorado Constitution would be gone forever.

As such, the proposal enables the Colorado legislature to tax at will, while deleting the Colorado Constitution limitation to tax.

Whether you are for or against this is up to you. You decide.

Form 1065 and 1120-S Filing Deadlines and Late Filing Penalties

Updated September 12, 2026. Covers calendar-year 2025 returns filed in 2026.

For calendar-year 2025 partnership and S corporation returns, the regular federal filing deadline was March 16, 2026. A timely, valid extension generally moves the deadline to September 15, 2026. The March date shifts because March 15 falls on a Sunday. Fiscal-year businesses and taxpayers covered by special relief may have different deadlines. See the IRS instructions for Form 1065 and Form 1120-S.

Missing the deadline can create a substantial penalty even when the business owes no federal income tax. Before calculating exposure, establish the return year, whether an extension was valid, and how many people held ownership interests during the year.

When are partnership and S corporation returns due?

Federal return for calendar year 2025 Regular filing deadline Extended filing deadline with a timely, valid extension
Partnership Form 1065 March 16, 2026 September 15, 2026
S corporation Form 1120-S March 16, 2026 September 15, 2026

For a fiscal-year entity, the general deadline is the 15th day of the third month after its tax year ends, subject to applicable exceptions. Do not use the calendar-year dates without confirming the business’s tax year. IRS Form 1065 instructions, IRS Form 1120-S instructions.

How does Form 7004 extend the deadline?

Most partnerships and S corporations use Form 7004 to request an automatic six-month filing extension. It generally must be filed by the original return deadline. Keep proof of timely filing and, for an electronic submission, the acceptance acknowledgment.

A business extension does not extend an owner’s individual return. An owner’s personal extension likewise does not extend the business return. Filing Form 7004 also does not extend the time to pay tax that is due. IRS Form 7004 instructions.

September 15 is normally the end of the regular extension for a calendar-year entity. However, an IRS disaster postponement or other applicable special relief can change the deadline. Check the relief announcement’s covered taxpayers, locations, and filing periods before relying on a later date. IRS disaster tax relief.

How much is the late-filing penalty?

For returns required to be filed in 2026, the basic federal late-filing penalty is generally $255 per partner or shareholder for each month or part of a month, for up to 12 months. Count everyone who was a partner or shareholder at any time during the tax year, rather than just the owners remaining at year-end. The amount is adjusted for inflation, so use the rate applicable to the return’s required filing year. IRS failure-to-file penalty guidance.

For the basic penalty, the calculation is:

$255 × number of partners or shareholders × months or partial months late, up to 12.

Owners during the tax year 1 penalty month 2 penalty months 12 penalty months
2 $510 $1,020 $6,120
4 $1,020 $2,040 $12,240

These examples exclude other penalties and assume no relief applies. An S corporation owing tax can face additional tax-based penalties. Missing or incorrect Schedules K-1 can also create separate exposure. IRS Form 1120-S instructions.

Does October 1 start a second penalty month?

No. Penalty months are measured from the applicable due date, rather than by counting calendar months touched by the delay.

For a return validly extended to September 15, 2026, the first penalty month runs September 16 through October 15. Filing on October 2 falls within that first period. With four owners, the basic penalty would therefore be $1,020, assuming no special relief or other penalties. Filing on October 16 enters a second penalty month and increases that amount to $2,040. These examples apply the IRS’s due-date-based method for counting penalty months. IRS penalty computation guidance.

Can a penalty apply when no tax is owed?

Yes. The partnership filing penalty concerns the required information return and can apply even without entity-level income tax. An incomplete return can also trigger a penalty. IRS Form 1065 instructions.

S corporations generally pass income and other tax items through to shareholders, but some owe entity-level taxes, including certain built-in gains taxes. Saying that no tax is ever due with Form 1120-S would be inaccurate. IRS Form 1120-S instructions.

What should you do after missing the deadline?

  1. Verify the filing history. Locate the return, extension, electronic acceptance records, and any IRS notices.
  2. Finish the required filing. Reconcile the books and prepare complete returns and owner schedules promptly.
  3. Check the penalty calculation. Compare the IRS’s due date, owner count, applicable rate, and number of late months against the records.
  4. Evaluate relief. Identify the applicable relief provision and gather the evidence it requires.

Keep a dated chronology of what prevented filing and what steps the business took to resolve the problem. If a notice has arrived, preserve it and track its response deadline. For assistance with overdue filings, see our unfiled tax returns service.

Can the IRS remove the penalty?

Depending on the facts, reasonable cause may support relief. Certain small partnerships may qualify under Revenue Procedure 84-35. Having ten or fewer partners is only one condition: partner eligibility, consistent proportional allocations, timely owner reporting, and the other IRS requirements must also be checked. This partnership provision is not an S corporation exemption. IRS CP162A notice guidance.

Administrative relief may also apply. The IRS describes a transition beginning in summer 2026 from First Time Abate to Automatic Exemption from Penalty for eligible returns, including Forms 1065 and 1120-S. Eligibility depends on the applicable period and compliance history. If a penalty was assessed, check whether relief was applied or needs to be requested. IRS administrative penalty relief.

For help evaluating a notice and supporting a request, see our tax penalty abatement service.

Colorado DR 0106 has a different deadline

The federal September deadline should not be confused with Colorado’s filing schedule. For calendar-year 2025, Colorado DR 0106 is generally due April 15, 2026, with an automatic six-month filing extension to October 15, 2026. The state extension does not extend the payment deadline. Colorado’s 2025 DR 0106 instructions.

See our separate discussion of Colorado partnership and S corporation filing requirements for the state return.

Help with a partnership or S corporation return

If your business needs a return prepared, review our Form 1065 partnership tax services or Form 1120-S S corporation tax services. If you received a penalty notice, bring the notice, extension confirmation, filed return, and ownership history to a consultation so the filing obligation and potential relief can be evaluated together.

Employment Tax Audit – 941, 940, W2. Footnote on IRS downsizing

We recently represented several taxpayers in employment tax audits stemming from discrepancies between Forms 941 and W-2.

Employment tax should have zero errors: quarterly 941s should match year-end W-2s and the W-3. The 940 should also match. Finally, the income tax return (1040 schedule C, 1120S, 1065, 1120) should match as far as wages, payroll tax. If any of these are inconsistent, a payroll tax audit could follow suit.

Typically there are gaps in 941s filed. There might be gaps in 941 payments. In other words, if the tax shown in the W-2 plus the employer side (15.3 percent) does not match deposits, an audit could be triggered.

Once an audit is triggered, it is more expansive in scope and years. The income tax return is reviewed for irregularities, and the number of years reviewed is expanded. In addition, state issues are reviewed such as state unemployment tax payment, rate. Employee benefits are reviewed such as health insurance, pension/profit sharing plans, automobile use, allowances, reimbursements.

Employee records are checked triggering potential illegal alien employment audit such as with employee Forms I-9 and W-4. Cash disbursements are checked, vendor payments, 1099s. All books and records can be checked, including accounting software. These audit exams are handled by IRS Revenue Agents with vast power.

It has been my recent experience that the IRS downsizing efforts have taken a toll. I have heard repeatedly from various agents about the stress and effects throughout the entire country. I recently heard of an effort of 40% downsizing. Many agents do not know if they can complete an audit because they might be terminated. I just thought it was interesting to note the real time effect.

Payroll filings should be reconciled with the underlying business income-tax return before inconsistencies attract IRS attention. Our tax compliance review can examine returns, payroll filings, information returns, and supporting records for discrepancies before an examination begins.

IRS Tax Preparer Audit Representation

An IRS tax preparer audit examines the preparer’s compliance obligations, which can differ from the issues in an individual client’s audit. Philip Falco, Attorney & CPA, has represented tax preparers selected for examination under the IRS paid preparer due diligence program. Representation can address both the supporting records and the response to the examiner.

If you received a letter or examination request, gather the complete notice and its attachments before responding. Identify the tax years, returns, requested records, and response date so the scope of the examination can be reviewed.

What Does an IRS Tax Preparer Audit Examine?

A due diligence examination may focus on how you determined eligibility for specified tax credits or head-of-household filing status, what questions you asked, and which records you kept. The IRS describes these obligations in its tax preparer due diligence rules.

The particular request may involve client interviews, dependents, income and expenses, or inconsistencies in information supplied by clients. Review the actual examination letter rather than assuming that every preparer audit has the same scope.

Form 8867 and Due Diligence

Form 8867, Paid Preparer’s Due Diligence Checklist, concerns specified credits and head-of-household filing status. Completing a checklist is part of the process; the underlying questions, computations, and documentation also matter.

The IRS knowledge and recordkeeping guidance explains the need for reasonable follow-up when information appears incorrect, inconsistent, or incomplete. A useful response connects the preparer’s work to the records available for each return under review.

Records to Assemble Before Responding

  • The IRS letter, attachments, prior correspondence, and any proposed examination findings.
  • The returns identified in the request and associated Forms 8867 and credit worksheets.
  • Client interview notes, follow-up questions and answers, and records of how, when, and from whom information was obtained.
  • Copies of client documents relied upon in preparing the returns.
  • Relevant preparation procedures, staff training materials, and review records.

Preserve existing records and identify gaps accurately. Do not reconstruct a file in a way that makes a later explanation appear to be a contemporaneous note.

Responding to the Examiner

Start by matching each request to the relevant return, client file, and supporting explanation. Separate records that exist from items requiring clarification. Review the scope and response date before producing documents or agreeing to an interview.

An attorney and CPA can help evaluate the request, organize the accounting evidence, explain disputed issues, and communicate with the IRS under the agreed representation scope. An examination does not by itself establish that a preparer violated a requirement.

Proposed Penalties and Representation Scope

Due diligence failures can result in preparer penalties under Internal Revenue Code section 6695(g). The issues, applicable tax years, and facts determine the potential exposure and response. If the examination raises concerns about intentional conduct, discuss those concerns with counsel before responding.

A consultation can help identify the immediate issues and records needed. Ongoing examination work, document preparation, correspondence, and representation require a separate engagement.

Discuss Your Tax Preparer Audit

Schedule a $500 Tax Attorney Consultation. The fee includes up to one hour of total attorney time for document review, analysis, preparation, and the telephone consultation combined. Bring the IRS notice and any approaching response dates.

Charitable Remainder Annuity Trust – High Value, Low Basis Property for Income Stream

So you are getting older and have been successful in life. Now you own property, perhaps real estate, that has substantially increased in value but has a low adjusted basis. If you were to liquidate that property you would incur a large tax liability.

You want to tap into that value by way of an income stream. One solution is to contribute that property to a Charitable Remainder Annuity Trust (CRAT), the CRAT then sells the property tax free and purchases an annuity. But is the receipt of the annuity income tax free (perhaps a single premium immediate annuity SPIA)? That would be too good to be true, unfortunately per Internal Revenue Code 664. Here’s how that breaks down.

What is a Charitable Remainder Annuity Trust – CRAT?

The basic concept of a CRAT involves a grantor’s transfer of property to an irrevocable trust, the terms of which provide for the payment of a specified amount, at least annually, to the grantor or other designated noncharitable beneficiaries for life or another predetermined period of time up to twenty years. I.R.C. § 664(d). What remains in the trust after the expiration of that period (which cannot be less than 10 percent of the initial net fair market value of all property placed in the trust, I.R.C. § 664(d)(1)(D)) must be transferred to one or more qualified charitable organizations or continue to be held in the trust for the benefit of such organizations. In short, unlike an immediate gift to charity, a contribution to
a CRAT blends the philanthropic intentions of a donor with his or her financial needs or the financial needs of others.

As a rule, the grantor recognizes no gain when transferring appreciated property to a CRAT. Moreover,
because CRATs are exempt from income tax, a CRAT can sell appreciated property without itself paying tax on the sale. See I.R.C. § 664(c)(1); Treas. Reg. § 1.664-1(a)(1)(i).

But that does not mean that the grantor or other noncharitable CRAT beneficiaries do not have to pay tax with respect to distributions from the CRAT. “Although a [CRAT] is itself exempt from income tax
and, therefore, pays no tax on any of its taxable income, the annuity . . . payments made to the noncharitable beneficiaries carry out taxable income that is subject to tax at the beneficiary level.” Alpha I, L.P. v. United States, 682 F.3d 1009, 1015 (Fed. Cir. 2012) (stating the rule and citing section 664(b) and (c)(1)). This is so because when property is transferred to a CRAT, the basis of the property in the CRAT’s hands generally is the same as it would be in the hands of the grantor. See I.R.C. § 1015(a) and (b); Treas. Reg. §§ 1.1015-1(a)(1), 1.1015-2(a)(1).

And when the CRAT sells the property, it realizes gain to the extent the amount realized from the sale exceeds its adjusted basis. I.R.C. § 1001; see also Treas. Reg. § 1.664-1(d)(1)(i) (discussing the assignment of income to categories at the CRAT level). Although not taxable to the CRAT, that gain must be tracked and affects the treatment of distributions from the CRAT. See, e.g., Treas. Reg. § 1.664-1(d)(1)(viii)
(providing examples illustrating the rules).

Congress has established specific ordering rules that govern the characterization and reporting of annuity amounts distributed by a CRAT to its income beneficiaries. See I.R.C. § 664(b). Under this regime, distributions from a CRAT to income beneficiaries are deemed to have the following character and to be distributed in the following order:
(1) as ordinary income, to the extent of the CRAT’s current and previously undistributed ordinary income;
(2) as capital gain, to the extent of the CRAT’s current and previously undistributed capital gain;
(3) as other income, to the extent of the CRAT’s current and previously undistributed other income; and
(4) as a nontaxable distribution of trust corpus.

CRATs are subject to strict reporting requirements to ensure compliance with the statutory ordering rules. See I.R.C. § 4947(a); Treas. Reg. § 1.664-1(a)(1)(ii). A CRAT must file an annual information return on Form 5227 reflecting its income, deductions, accumulations, and distributions for the year. See I.R.C. § 6011(a); Treas. Reg. § 53.6011-1(d). And it must issue to each income beneficiary a Schedule K–1 properly describing the tax character of all distributions. See I.R.C. § 6034A(a); Treas. Reg. § 1.6034-1(a).

For example, what CRAT earned was ordinary income because the properties the CRATs sold were subject to the rules of section 1245—hence, distributions to grantor would be ordinary income.

Charitable remainder trusts can affect capital-gain reporting, basis, Schedule K-1 income, charitable deductions, and the beneficiary’s individual tax return. These issues often arise as part of high-net-worth tax preparation and planning.

Transactions involving highly appreciated property, charitable structures, trusts, or the timing of a sale can also benefit from advance tax strategy and planning before the structure or disposition is finalized.

Gotcha: IRS Tax Return Proposed Changes CP2000 – Omitted 1099

We have handled the following situation many times so I figured I would write a post about it. This is very common.

The bad news. Taxpayer receives CP2000 from the IRS, which is IRS’s proposed changes to the 1040 tax return. IRS has a before (shown on return) and after column (as corrected by the IRS). Typically taxpayer has forgotten to include a 1099, such as a 1099-S from the sale of a home, or perhaps a 1099-MISC as to schedule C income.

Taxpayer is scratching his/her head thinking well no tax is owed since the gain from the sale of my home was less than the principal residence tax exclusion of $250,000 or $500,000 for married couples. True but the IRS wants to see the steps.

Also, you might think that the 1099-MISC income was included in schedule C gross income. True but the IRS wants to see the 1099 tied to gross income and reported with the return. In truth, IRS proposed change would double include that 1099 income since it was already included on your schedule C, but the IRS does not know that.

The IRS does not give taxpayers the benefit of the doubt. Taxpayers must apply appropriate tax rules in their return. The IRS assumes worst case scenario when proposing changes, which must then be disproved by the taxpayer. Give us a call to handle this for you.

If you go at it alone, you would have to correct the return and provide the correct documentation to the IRS. If the IRS accepts your corrections, the assessment will be adjusted correctly and you win, or at least set the record straight.

Tax Debt Collection: Statute of Limitations Tolling

The IRS has a limited amount of time to collect your tax debt. This blog post discusses some of your actions or reasons why that time period could be extended (tolled). To put it in simple terms, tolling is bad or hurts the taxpayer.

The IRS through the United States Department of Justice can file an action in the United States District Court pursuant to 26 U.S.C. 7401 to reduce your tax debt to judgment on the very last day of the expiration of the statute of limitations. If the action is timely, the statute of limitations is no longer relevant since (assuming a judgment is entered) the tax debt is reduced to judgment. As such, exact calculation of the statute of limitations is critical. Here are some matters that could have extended your period.

Absent events that toll the statute of limitations, 26 U.S.C. § 6502(a) provides a general ten-year collection statute of limitations starting on the date a tax is assessed. The collection statute of limitations is tolled under 26 U.S.C. § 6330(e) anytime there is pending a collection due process hearing under 26 U.S.C. § 6330(a)(3)(B). A taxpayer is entitled to request such a hearing before the IRS levies. See 26 U.S.C. § 6330(e).

The collection statute of limitations is further tolled under 26 U.S.C. § 6330(e) for 90 days after the day on which there is a final determination of a collection due process hearing under 26 U.S.C. § 6330(a)(3)(B).

The collection statute of limitations is also tolled when an offer to enter into an installment agreement is pending between the taxpayer and the IRS. See 26 U.S.C. §§ 6502(a)(2), 6331(i), (k). The collection statute of limitations is tolled for thirty days following the rejection or termination of an installment agreement. See 26 U.S.C. § 6331(i), (k).

So if your installment is pending for a year and then terminated, the statute of limitations would be tolled for a year plus thirty days.

The statute of limitations tolling begins on the day you, the taxpayer, request an installment agreement even though it could take months for the IRS to accept or reject that request. For example, assume the IRS receives your request on July 20, 2015, to enter into an installment agreement for tax years 2011 and 2012. That request was pending until December 16, 2015 when the IRS granted the installment agreement request for tax years 2011 and 2012. Accordingly, the pending installment agreement request tolled the collection statute of limitations for tax years 2011 and 2012 for at least 149 days (July 20, 2015 to December 16, 2015).

There is some debate over the 90 day period. Under 26 U.S.C. § 6330(e), the statute of limitation period shall not expire “before the 90th day after the day on which there is a final determination in such hearing.” The collection statute of limitations is not further tolled for 90 days but if the final determination is less than 90 days from the date the period expires, then the statute of limitation period is from the 90th day after the date of final determination. See also Reg. § 301.6330-1(g)(3).

related content:

Unpaid taxes – Offers in Compromise

Tax Liens, Tax Levies, Collection Due Process Hearings

If you would like an analysis of your collection period statute of limitations, please contact me (303) 626-7000 phil@coloradolegal.com.

New Entity EIN and Tax Classification

This is one of the most important steps that could impact the entire future of your new business. Take your time before applying for an EIN with the Internal Revenue Service. Severe adverse tax consequences could impact the future of your entity.

Entity classification is a tax-planning decision, not merely an administrative filing. Our tax strategy and planning service evaluates entity choice and other decisions before they create long-term tax consequences.

Name selection. If you choose a name with Corp, or Inc, the default entity will likely be a C Corporation. Taxpayers almost always do not intend on being C Corporations.

If you choose LLC (limited liability company) and you are a sole owner it will most likely default to schedule C on your 1040.

In addition, if you answer questions indicating that you will have payroll, and you very well could, it will trigger the filing of payroll forms typically 940 and 941 with automatic filing dates required, which in turn trigger Colorado state withholding filings, Colorado Department of Labor and Employment, and possibly the Denver Head Tax. In addition, it could trigger worker’s compensation insurance.

Save the letter you get from the IRS SS-4 or IRS CP 575 A for the life of your business.

Tax Tips:

  • Avoid Corp or Inc unless you know exactly what you are doing
  • Be prepared to set up State and local payroll accounts if you have employees
  • Most LLCs will be on schedule C of your 1040, or form 1065 if you have more than just you as a partner

Once the entity classification is established, the ongoing filing obligations should be coordinated with the business and owner returns. See our business tax preparation service for LLC, S corporation, partnership, and closely held business filings.

S Corp Requirements (disproportionate distributions)

S Corporations can only have one class of stock. An argument can be unsuccessfully made that uneven de facto distributions to shareholders would be more than one class of stock. However, so long as the corporate documents call for even distributions all is ok even if uneven distributions subsequently occur.

The legal basis for this is found in the regulations: the regulation tells the IRS to focus on shareholder rights under a corporation’s governing documents, not what shareholders actually do. The regulation states that uneven distributions don’t mean that the corporation has more than one class of stock. Treas. Reg. § 1.1361-1(l)(2) (“[A] corporation is not treated as having more than one class of stock so long as the governing provisions provide for identical distribution and liquidation rights . . . .”).

Taking a step back, the first rule is that shareholders have to choose to be taxed as an S corporation. Shareholders do so by filling out a Form 2553, Election by a Small Business Corporation, that they file with the IRS. See Treas. Reg. § 1.1362-6(a)(2)(i). Once the IRS approves, the election remains effective indefinitely. § 1362(c); see Mourad v. Commissioner, 121 T.C. 1, 4 (2003), aff’d, 387 F.3d 27 (1st Cir. 2004).

A great many small and medium-sized businesses elect S corporation status because the Code affords them special treatment—income earned by the corporation escapes corporate-level taxation. Mourad, 121 T.C. at 3; see §§ 1363, 1366. That income is instead “passed through” to its shareholders pro rata. See §§ 1363, 1366. But electing to be an S corporation is not enough. The Code has several other requirements. These include having no more than 100 shareholders, having only shareholders who are individuals—or certain trusts or nonprofits—and not having any nonresident alien shareholders. § 1361(b)(1). The parties don’t dispute that Schricker met these requirements.

There’s one other requirement. Section 1361(b)(1)(D) allows a corporation to be an S corporation only if it has no more than one class of stock. What does that mean? Section 1361 doesn’t say, but we know that run-of-the-mill debt isn’t a second class of stock. § 1361(c)(5)(A). And neither are differences in common-stock voting rights. § 1361(c)(4).

The regulation gives us a little more help. It generally treats a corporation as having only one class of stock so long as all the shares confer equal rights to dividends and liquidation proceeds. Treas. Reg. § 1.1361-1(l)(1) (“[A] corporation is treated as having only one class of stock if all outstanding shares of stock of the corporation confer identical rights to distribution and liquidation proceeds”).

The regulation also tells us to determine whether stock confers identical rights to distributions and liquidation proceeds based on the corporation’s governing provisions. Id. subpara. (2)(i). These are
documents like a corporate charter, articles of incorporation, and bylaws. Id. The IRS has said it won’t treat any disproportionate distributions made by a corporation as violating the one-class-of-stock requirement if the governing provisions provide for identical rights. Rev. Proc. 2022-19, § 3.02, 2022-41 I.R.B. 282, 286.

As you can see this topic is a Pandora’s box. Luckily we have some common-sense regulations to pave the way forward, thank you Department of Treasury 🙂

Distribution issues should also be reviewed as part of S corporation tax return preparation, because distributions interact with shareholder basis, Schedule K-1 reporting, and the shareholder’s Form 1040.

Guilty until Proven Innocent? Tax Court Burden of Proof

Who has the upper hand in Tax Court, the IRS or the Taxpayer? You decide.

You are considering filing a petition with the United States Tax Court perhaps regarding your Notice of Deficiency post IRS audit. Here are a few rules of play to be aware of.

The IRS’s determinations in a notice of deficiency are generally presumed correct, and taxpayers bear the burden of proving them erroneous. Rule 142(a); Welch v. Helvering, 290 U.S. 111, 115 (1933). This puts the main hurdle on the Taxpayer. To put it in common terms, the Taxpayer is presumed guilty, not innocent (these are civil matters, not criminal so this is an analogy). Walking into Tax Court, Taxpayer must prove the IRS’s position is wrong.

All is not hopeless. However, if a taxpayer produces credible evidence with respect to one or more factual issues relevant to the taxpayer’s tax liability, the burden of proof may shift to the IRS as to that issue or issues. § 7491(a)(1). Likewise, the IRS’s determination does not receive a presumption of correctness if the determination is shown to be arbitrary and capricious. Helvering v. Taylor, 293 U.S. 507, 514 (1935); Cohen v. Commissioner, 266 F.2d 5, 11 (9th Cir. 1959), remanding T.C. Memo. 1957-172. Also, the IRS bears the burden of proving new matters asserted in its answer. See Rule 142(a).

Tax Court proceedings are conducted in accordance with the Federal Rules of Evidence. § 7453; Rule 143(a).

Section 7491(a)(1) provides that if, in any court proceeding, a taxpayer introduces credible evidence with respect to any factual issue relevant to ascertaining the liability of the taxpayer for any tax imposed by subtitle A or B, the IRS shall have the burden of proof with respect to that issue. See Higbee v. Commissioner, 116 T.C. 438, 440–41 (2001). For the burden to be placed on the IRS under this section, however, the taxpayer must demonstrate that he has: (1) complied with the requirements under the Code to substantiate any item, (2) maintained all records required under the Code, and (3) cooperated with reasonable requests by the Secretary for witnesses, information, documents, meetings, and interviews. See § 7491(a)(2); Higbee, 116 T.C. at 440–41.

CFO and Board Advisory for Companies and Investment Funds

Philip Falco, Attorney and CPA, advises business owners, executives, boards, and investment managers on financial, tax, and legal matters. Engagements can focus on a specific issue, such as following up on internal audit findings or evaluating the tax implications of an entity structure, or provide ongoing advisory support.

Who This Advisory Service Is For

  • Private equity firms and portfolio companies. Review portfolio-company reporting and controls, evaluate tax and entity-structure questions, and help management turn audit findings into changes in policy and practice.
  • Hedge funds and other investment managers. Advise on management-company tax and entity structure, internal financial controls, and issues that call for coordination with fund administrators, auditors, and outside counsel.
  • Mid-sized and large companies. Support executives, boards, and audit committees with internal audit follow-up, fraud prevention and detection, and review of financial practices that may create legal exposure.
  • Closely held and growing businesses. Advise owners on tax planning and compliance, entity structure, and financial reporting as the business grows.

Financial Reporting, Tax and Legal Coordination

  • Review financial reporting alongside the business’s tax and legal structure.
  • Identify compliance and documentation issues that need follow-up with the company’s existing advisers.
  • Discuss internal-review recommendations, related policies, and controls intended to address fraud and legal exposure.
  • Connect ownership and business decisions with the appropriate tax, accounting, and legal work.

The engagement defines the actual advisory work and the responsibilities of the firm and the company’s existing advisers.

Formal CFO and Board Appointments

Advisory engagements have a defined scope. A formal appointment as CFO, another officer, or a director requires a separate written agreement and appropriate company approval.

Records to Bring to an Initial Review

Start with available financial statements, budgets or internal reports, prior tax returns, payroll summaries, formation documents, and an ownership chart. Include relevant board or management materials and any internal-review recommendations you want addressed. Identify missing records and the business decision or deadline that prompted the review.

Define the Engagement and Next Steps

  1. Identify the business need. Explain the reporting, compliance, governance, or transaction issue and who is currently responsible for it.
  2. Review the available records. Identify gaps, existing advisers, and work that may need a separate specialist engagement.
  3. Agree on scope. Confirm the advisory responsibilities, work covered, timing, fees, and any ongoing coordination. A formal appointment requires its own agreement.

The initial consultation is separate from ongoing advisory work, return preparation, and any formal CFO or board role.

Discuss CFO and Board Advisory

Schedule a $500 Tax Attorney Consultation. The fee includes up to one hour of total attorney time for document review, analysis, preparation, and the telephone consultation combined. Tax-return preparation, filings, and representation require a separate engagement.

Ongoing CFO and advisory work is most effective when financial reporting, payroll, tax planning, and annual returns are coordinated. Our business tax preparation service handles that annual filing component for closely held businesses and their owners.

Businesses that need recurring tax guidance without a full CFO engagement may also use our year-round tax advisory service for proactive tax planning and ongoing coordination throughout the year.

City & County of Denver Taxes

So what are these mysterious taxes? Here they are:

Sales Tax – On the purchase price for all sales and purchases of tangible personal property, etc. Return due on or before the twentieth (20 th ) day of each month for sales occurring in the preceding calendar month

Use Tax – There is levied and there shall be collected and paid a tax in the amount stated in this article, by every person exercising the taxable privilege of storing, using, distributing or consuming in the city tangible personal property, or a product or service subject to the provisions of this article, purchased at retail, for said exercise of said privilege, etc. Return due on or before the twentieth (20 th ) day of each month for sales occurring in the preceding calendar month.

Lodger’s Tax –  There is hereby levied and shall be collected and paid a tax by every person exercising the taxable privilege of purchasing lodging, etc. Return due on or before the twentieth (20 th ) day of each month for sales occurring in the preceding calendar month.

Employee Occupational Privilege Tax – There is hereby levied by the city upon and there shall be collected monthly from and paid to the manager by each employee who performs services within the city for any period of time in a calendar month for an employer, an employee’s occupational privilege tax, at the rate of five dollars and seventy-five cents ($5.75) per month for each and every month in which such employee is, for any period of time, so employed. Return due on or before the last day of each month for the taxes required to be remitted for the preceding calendar month.

Business Occupational Privilege Tax – There is hereby levied by the city upon, and there shall be collected monthly from and paid to the manager by, every person engaged in any business, trade, occupation, profession or calling of any kind having a fixed or transitory situs within the city, for any period of time in a calendar month within the city, a business occupational privilege tax in the sum of four dollars ($4.00) per month for the first owner, partner, manager or employee, and the additional sum of four dollars ($4.00) per month for each and every additional owner, partner, manager or employee who performs within the city for any period of time in a calendar month any services or other activities in the operation of such business, trade, occupation, profession or calling within the city. Return due on or before the last day of each month for taxes required to be withheld for the preceding calendar month.

Facilities Development Admissions Tax – “Admission” shall mean the right to an entrance and an occupancy of a seat or an entrance alone, of a person who, for a consideration by whatever name known, including involuntary “contributions,” uses, possesses or has the right to use or possess entrance and occupancy of a seat or an entrance alone to any entertainment, amusement, athletic event, exhibition or other production or assembly staged, produced, convened or held at or on any facility or property owned or leased by the city, including, but not limited to, the following facilities: the Denver Coliseum Complex; the Red Rocks Theatre; Phipps Auditorium; the Denver Performing Arts Complex; the National Western Stock Show Complex; and the Colorado Convention Center. Return due on or before the fifteenth day of each month for sales occurring in the preceding calendar month

Telecommunications Tax – There is levied a tax on the privilege of engaging in the telecommunications business within the city upon each business so engaged one and twelve-hundredths dollars ($1.12) for each account of such business regarding a customer for which local exchange telecommunications are provided by said business within the city. Return due on or before the twentieth (20 th ) day of each calendar month for taxes required to be remitted for the preceding calendar month.

Buyer beware!  Returns required upon sale of business; purchaser subject to lien. (a) Any taxpayer who shall sell out a business or stock of goods or shall quit business shall be required to make out a return as provided in this chapter within ten (10) days after the date the taxpayer sold out the business or stock of goods or quit business, and a successor in business shall be required to withhold sufficient of the purchase money to cover the amount of the tax due and unpaid until such time as the former owner shall produce a receipt from the manager showing that the taxes have been paid or a certificate that no taxes are due. (b) If the purchaser of a business or stock of goods shall fail to withhold the purchase money as provided in subsection (a), and the tax shall be due and unpaid after the ten (10) day period allowed, the purchaser, as well as the taxpayer, shall be personally liable for the payment of the taxes unpaid by the former owner. Likewise, anyone who takes any stock of goods or business fixtures of or used by any employer under lease, title-retaining contract or other contract arrangement, by purchase, foreclosure sale or otherwise, takes same subject to the lien for any delinquent taxes owed by such employer and shall be liable for the payment of all delinquent taxes of such prior owner, not, however, exceeding the value of the property so taken or acquired.

Cryptocurrency Tax Compliance

We are now performing tax compliance for taxpayers with Cryptocurrency, the Cryptocurrency net worth of which exceeds 1 million (U.S. convertible).  We are the best at what we do.

Tax year 2017 is a critical tax year for Cryptocurrency.  Getting 2017 correct will provide a foundation for huge gains in later years.  You must seize the moment.

The Internal Revenue Service is focusing on noncompliant taxpayers in this space.  This is evident by the John Doe Summons issued on Coinbase.  As many of us have read, the Internal Revenue Service has obtained information about 14,355 Coinbase account holders.  Coinbase has been ordered to provide the IRS with the taxpayer’s name, etc., for those individuals who have bought, sold, sent, or received more than $20,000.  In addition, the Securities and Exchange Commission is paying attention, which is evident by statements made about Initial Coin Offerings (ICO’s).

The day of tax reckoning is inevitable.  Time is of the essence to properly disclose huge transactions.  Please feel free to call us.  (303) 626-7000.